HR 452 · 112th Congress 2011–2013, ended

Medicare Decisions Accountability Act of 2011

Introduced Jan 26, 2011 Originated House Sponsor David P. Roe R-TN

Latest action · Mar 16, 2012 Placed on the Union Calendar, Calendar No. 284.

Progress

Where this bill reached, and when. A stage with no date was not reached; one that failed a vote and later carried shows the date it carried.

IntroducedJan 26, 2011
Passed HouseNot reached
Passed SenateNot reached
To the PresidentNot reached
Became lawNot reached

Summary

(This measure has not been amended since it was reported to the House as Part I on March 13, 2012. The summary of that version is repeated here.)

Medicare Decisions Accountability Act of 2011 - Repeals sections of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) (and restores provisions of law amended by such sections) related to the establishment of an Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAD) to develop and submit detailed proposals to reduce the per capita rate of growth in Medicare spending to the President for Congress to consider.

(Retains, however, requirements for expedited consideration of IPAB-related proposals to reduce Medicare spending.)

Cosponsors 234

Members who signed on, in the order they did. Signatures ran from Jan 26, 2011 to Mar 6, 2012; 23 are original cosponsors, there from the day it was introduced.

Seat	Cosponsor		Signed on
R-MS	Alan Nunnelee	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-FL	Bill Posey	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-MO	Billy Long	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-CA	Dana Rohrabacher	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-CO	Doug Lamborn	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-CA	Duncan Hunter	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-AR	Eric A. "Rick" Crawford	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-CA	Gary G. Miller	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-PA	Glenn Thompson	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-NC	Howard Coble	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TN	John J. Duncan, Jr.	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TX	K. Michael Conaway	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-GA	Lynn A. Westmoreland	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TN	Marsha Blackburn	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TX	Michael C. Burgess	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-CO	Mike Coffman	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-GA	Paul C. Broun	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TX	Pete Sessions	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TX	Ralph M. Hall	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-NJ	Rodney P. Frelinghuysen	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TX	Ron Paul	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-FL	Thomas J. Rooney	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-NC	Walter B. Jones	Original	Jan 26, 2011
R-TX	Bill Flores		Feb 9, 2011
R-LA	John Fleming		Feb 9, 2011
R-NV	Joseph J. Heck		Feb 9, 2011
R-OH	Patrick J. Tiberi		Feb 9, 2011
R-GA	Phil Gingrey		Feb 9, 2011
R-NC	Renee L. Ellmers		Feb 9, 2011
R-CA	Tom McClintock		Feb 9, 2011
R-WV	David B. McKinley		Feb 18, 2011
R-FL	Jeff Miller		Feb 18, 2011
R-NY	Nan A. S. Hayworth		Feb 18, 2011
D-MA	Michael E. Capuano		Mar 1, 2011
R-NY	Michael G. Grimm		Mar 1, 2011
R-VA	H. Morgan Griffith		Mar 3, 2011
R-TX	Randy Neugebauer		Mar 3, 2011
R-NM	Stevan Pearce		Mar 3, 2011
R-PA	Tim Murphy		Mar 3, 2011
R-MO	W. Todd Akin		Mar 3, 2011
R-IL	Aaron Schock		Mar 10, 2011
R-AZ	Jeff Flake		Mar 10, 2011
R-SC	Joe Wilson		Mar 10, 2011
R-TX	Kenny Marchant		Mar 10, 2011
R-AZ	Paul A. Gosar		Mar 10, 2011
R-OH	Robert E. Latta		Mar 10, 2011
D-NV	Shelley Berkley		Mar 10, 2011
R-MI	Dan Benishek		Mar 15, 2011
D-NC	Larry Kissell		Mar 15, 2011
R-MI	Thaddeus G. McCotter		Mar 15, 2011
R-PA	Tom Marino		Mar 15, 2011
R-PA	Michael G. Fitzpatrick		Mar 17, 2011
R-MI	Mike Rogers		Mar 29, 2011
R-MD	Andy Harris		Mar 30, 2011
R-IN	Dan Burton		Mar 30, 2011
R-IN	Todd Young		Mar 30, 2011
R-GA	Tom Price		Mar 30, 2011
R-OK	James Lankford		Apr 1, 2011
R-NJ	Jon Runyan		Apr 1, 2011
R-WV	Shelley Moore Capito		Apr 1, 2011
R-LA	Rodney Alexander		Apr 4, 2011
R-MS	Gregg Harper		Apr 8, 2011
R-NE	Lee Terry		Apr 8, 2011
R-AL	Mike Rogers		Apr 8, 2011
R-TX	John Abney Culberson		Apr 12, 2011
R-TX	Louie Gohmert		Apr 12, 2011
R-TX	Michael T. McCaul		Apr 12, 2011
R-TX	Pete Olson		Apr 12, 2011
R-TX	Blake Farenthold		Apr 14, 2011
R-TX	Jeb Hensarling		Apr 14, 2011
R-CA	Ken Calvert		Apr 14, 2011
R-KS	Lynn Jenkins		Apr 14, 2011
R-VA	Robert J. Wittman		Apr 14, 2011
R-OH	Steve Austria		Apr 14, 2011
R-OH	Steve Stivers		Apr 14, 2011
D-PA	Allyson Y. Schwartz		Apr 15, 2011
R-LA	Charles W. Boustany, Jr.		Apr 15, 2011
R-UT	Jason Chaffetz		Apr 15, 2011
R-TX	Kevin Brady		Apr 15, 2011
R-TX	Lamar Smith		Apr 15, 2011
R-NJ	Leonard Lance		Apr 15, 2011
R-KY	Brett Guthrie		May 2, 2011
R-PA	Charles W. Dent		May 2, 2011
R-IN	Larry Bucshon		May 2, 2011
R-MN	Michele Bachmann		May 2, 2011
R-PA	Patrick Meehan		May 2, 2011
R-OH	Steve Chabot		May 2, 2011
R-MS	Steven M. Palazzo		May 2, 2011
R-AR	Tim Griffin		May 2, 2011
R-KS	Tim Huelskamp		May 2, 2011
R-OH	Bill Johnson		May 3, 2011
R-TX	Francisco "Quico" Canseco		May 3, 2011
R-KY	Geoff Davis		May 3, 2011
I-MI	Justin Amash		May 4, 2011
R-IL	Peter J. Roskam		May 4, 2011
R-WI	Reid J. Ribble		May 4, 2011
R-MO	Blaine Luetkemeyer		May 10, 2011
R-LA	Jeffrey M. Landry		May 10, 2011
R-TX	John R. Carter		May 10, 2011
R-SC	Mick Mulvaney		May 10, 2011
R-TN	Scott DesJarlais		May 10, 2011
R-AR	Steve Womack		May 10, 2011
R-IN	Todd Rokita		May 10, 2011
R-PA	Todd Russell Platts		May 10, 2011
R-IA	Tom Latham		May 10, 2011
R-MI	Bill Huizenga		May 11, 2011
R-AZ	David Schweikert		May 11, 2011
R-TN	Diane Black		May 11, 2011
R-ID	Raul R. Labrador		May 11, 2011
R-AZ	Benjamin Quayle		May 13, 2011
R-AZ	Trent Franks		May 13, 2011
R-CA	Brian P. Bilbray		May 23, 2011
R-WA	Cathy McMorris Rodgers		May 23, 2011
R-WA	Jaime Herrera Beutler		May 23, 2011
R-WA	David G. Reichert		May 24, 2011
R-TX	Sam Johnson		May 24, 2011
R-KY	Ed Whitfield		May 25, 2011
R-NH	Frank C. Guinta		May 25, 2011
D-CA	Linda T. Sánchez		May 25, 2011
R-FL	Steve Southerland II		May 25, 2011
R-FL	Ileana Ros-Lehtinen		May 31, 2011
R-SC	Trey Gowdy		May 31, 2011
R-FL	C. W. Bill Young		Jun 2, 2011
R-IL	Donald A. Manzullo		Jun 2, 2011
R-MI	Candice S. Miller		Jun 13, 2011
D-PA	Chaka Fattah		Jun 13, 2011
R-NJ	Christopher H. Smith		Jun 13, 2011
D-FL	Kathy Castor		Jun 13, 2011
R-CA	Jeff Denham		Jun 14, 2011
R-CA	Mary Bono		Jun 14, 2011
R-KS	Mike Pompeo		Jun 14, 2011
R-IL	Robert J. Dold		Jun 14, 2011
R-MT	Denny Rehberg		Jun 15, 2011
R-GA	Austin Scott		Jun 16, 2011
R-ND	Rick Berg		Jun 16, 2011
R-NY	Ann Marie Buerkle		Jun 21, 2011
R-NH	Charles F. Bass		Jun 21, 2011
R-TX	Ted Poe		Jun 21, 2011
R-LA	Bill Cassidy		Jun 23, 2011
R-FL	Daniel Webster		Jun 23, 2011
R-PA	Jim Gerlach		Jun 23, 2011
R-PA	Lou Barletta		Jun 23, 2011
R-TX	Mac Thornberry		Jun 23, 2011
R-VA	Robert Hurt		Jun 24, 2011
R-TN	Charles J. "Chuck" Fleischmann		Jul 6, 2011
R-FL	David Rivera		Jul 6, 2011
R-FL	Dennis A. Ross		Jul 6, 2011
R-CA	Edward R. Royce		Jul 6, 2011
R-KS	Kevin Yoder		Jul 6, 2011
R-PA	Mike Kelly		Jul 6, 2011
R-TN	Stephen Lee Fincher		Jul 6, 2011
R-LA	Steve Scalise		Jul 6, 2011
R-FL	Vern Buchanan		Jul 6, 2011
R-IL	Adam Kinzinger		Jul 7, 2011
R-TX	Kay Granger		Jul 7, 2011
R-OK	John Sullivan		Jul 8, 2011
R-IL	Randy Hultgren		Jul 8, 2011
R-CA	Daniel E. Lungren		Jul 11, 2011
D-VI	Donna M. Christensen		Jul 11, 2011
R-IN	Marlin A. Stutzman		Jul 11, 2011
R-MO	Vicky Hartzler		Jul 11, 2011
R-GA	Jack Kingston		Jul 14, 2011
R-AL	Mo Brooks		Jul 14, 2011
R-NC	Patrick T. McHenry		Jul 14, 2011
R-MI	Tim Walberg		Jul 14, 2011
R-MN	Erik Paulsen		Jul 19, 2011
R-CA	Howard P. "Buck" McKeon		Jul 19, 2011
R-AL	Jo Bonner		Jul 19, 2011
R-IL	John Shimkus		Jul 19, 2011
R-AL	Martha Roby		Jul 19, 2011
R-OK	Tom Cole		Jul 19, 2011
R-CA	Jerry Lewis		Jul 20, 2011
R-MO	Jo Ann Emerson		Jul 20, 2011
R-IL	Robert T. Schilling		Jul 20, 2011
R-PA	Bill Shuster		Jul 21, 2011
D-TX	Eddie Bernice Johnson		Jul 21, 2011
R-VA	J. Randy Forbes		Jul 21, 2011
R-NY	Peter T. King		Jul 21, 2011
R-UT	Rob Bishop		Jul 21, 2011
R-CO	Scott R. Tipton		Jul 21, 2011
R-WI	Sean P. Duffy		Jul 21, 2011
R-WY	Cynthia M. Lummis		Jul 22, 2011
R-SD	Kristi L. Noem		Jul 22, 2011
R-OH	James B. Renacci		Jul 25, 2011
R-SC	Tim Scott		Jul 25, 2011
R-NY	Tom Reed		Jul 25, 2011
R-VA	Bob Goodlatte		Jul 26, 2011
R-CA	Elton Gallegly		Jul 26, 2011
R-FL	Cliff Stearns		Jul 27, 2011
R-OH	Steven C. LaTourette		Jul 27, 2011
R-FL	Allen B. West		Jul 29, 2011
R-NY	Christopher P. Gibson		Jul 29, 2011
R-VA	E. Scott Rigell		Jul 29, 2011
R-OH	Jean Schmidt		Jul 29, 2011
R-FL	Mario Diaz-Balart		Jul 29, 2011
R-MD	Roscoe G. Bartlett		Jul 29, 2011
D-CA	Loretta Sanchez		Aug 1, 2011
D-NY	Timothy H. Bishop		Aug 1, 2011
R-OR	Greg Walden		Aug 9, 2011
R-NE	Jeff Fortenberry		Aug 9, 2011
R-OH	Michael R. Turner		Sep 7, 2011
R-MO	Sam Graves		Sep 7, 2011
R-AL	Spencer Bachus		Sep 7, 2011
R-IL	Judy Biggert		Sep 12, 2011
R-NJ	Frank A. LoBiondo		Sep 15, 2011
R-AK	Don Young		Sep 22, 2011
R-OK	Frank D. Lucas		Oct 5, 2011
R-IL	Joe Walsh		Oct 12, 2011
R-CA	John Campbell		Oct 25, 2011
R-IL	Timothy V. Johnson		Nov 3, 2011
D-MA	Barney Frank		Nov 29, 2011
R-NC	Sue Wilkins Myrick		Nov 29, 2011
R-CO	Cory Gardner		Dec 1, 2011
R-ID	Michael K. Simpson		Dec 1, 2011
R-OH	Bob Gibbs		Dec 6, 2011
D-CT	Joe Courtney		Dec 6, 2011
R-FL	Richard B. Nugent		Dec 6, 2011
R-FL	Gus M. Bilirakis		Dec 7, 2011
D-UT	Jim Matheson		Dec 12, 2011
D-CA	Joe Baca		Dec 12, 2011
R-FL	Sandy Adams		Dec 15, 2011
R-SC	Jeff Duncan		Jan 31, 2012
R-NV	Mark E. Amodei		Feb 1, 2012
D-GA	John Barrow		Feb 13, 2012
D-NJ	Bill Pascrell, Jr.		Feb 27, 2012
R-MN	John Kline		Feb 27, 2012
R-GA	Tom Graves		Feb 29, 2012
R-FL	Connie Mack		Mar 1, 2012
D-TX	Silvestre Reyes		Mar 1, 2012
R-FL	Ander Crenshaw		Mar 5, 2012
D-AR	Mike Ross		Mar 5, 2012
D-MO	Russ Carnahan		Mar 5, 2012
R-WA	Doc Hastings		Mar 6, 2012
R-AL	Robert B. Aderholt		Mar 6, 2012

Committees 3

Where it was sent and what each committee and subcommittee did with it, in order.

Chamber	Committee	What it did
House	Ways and Means Committee	Referred Jan 26, 2011Markup Mar 8, 2012Reported Mar 13, 2012
	Health Subcommittee	Referred Jan 27, 2011
House	Rules Committee	Referred Jan 26, 2011Discharged Mar 16, 2012
House	Energy and Commerce Committee	Referred Jan 26, 2011Markup Mar 6, 2012Reported Mar 16, 2012
	Health Subcommittee	Referred Feb 9, 2011Markup Feb 29, 2012Reported Feb 29, 2012

Actions 17

Everything that happened, newest first.

Mar 16, 2012Reported (Amended) by the Committee on Energy and Commerce. H. Rept. 112-412, Part II.
Mar 16, 2012Committee on Rules discharged.
Mar 16, 2012Placed on the Union Calendar, Calendar No. 284.
Mar 13, 2012Reported (Amended) by the Committee on Ways and Means. H. Rept. 112-412, Part I.
Mar 13, 2012House Committee on Rules Granted an extension for further consideration ending not later than March 16, 2012.

Show all 17 actions

Research

What has been written about this bill: committee reports, cost estimates, the sponsor’s authority statement, printed hearings and the Congressional Research Service’s work.

Committee reports

Congressional Budget Office cost estimate

Mar 8, 2012H.R. 452, Medicare Decisions Accountability Act of 2011As ordered reported by the House Committee on Energy and Commerce on March 6, 2012

Constitutional authority

Congress has the power to enact this legislation pursuant to the following: The repeal of this provision is consistent with the powers that are reserved to the States and to the people as expressed in Amendment X to the United States Constitution.

The sponsor’s statement, as printed in the page H510.

Printed hearings 1

Hearings whose printed record names this bill, newest first: hearings on it, and wider hearings where it came up.

Number	Hearing	Committee	Held
Serial No. 112-12	MEDICARE'S FUTURE: AN EXAMINATION OF THE INDEPENDENT PAYMENT ADVISORY BOARD88 pages	Budget Committee	Jul 12, 2011

CRS reports 1

Congressional Research Service work that CRS links to this bill or the law it became, newest first.

Cite it 1

Products on other subjects that cite it, usually among other measures.

Product	Title	Kind	Published
R41511	The Independent Payment Advisory Board Archived	Report	Apr 17, 2013

Titles 3

Every title it has carried, official and short, at each stage.

Official Title as Introduced: To repeal the provisions of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act providing for the Independent Payment Advisory Board.
Short Titles as Introduced: Medicare Decisions Accountability Act of 2011
Short Titles as Reported to House: Medicare Decisions Accountability Act of 2011

Subjects

Assigned by the Library of Congress. Policy area: Health.

Text 2

Each version as it was printed, newest first.

Mar 16, 2012Reported in House
Jan 26, 2011Introduced in House

Support LegiList

This page is free, carries no paywall, and is built and maintained by one person. If the record here is useful to you, a few dollars keeps it going.

$1 $5 $10

Processed by Stripe in a separate window. LegiList never sees card details.

Everything here is as published by Congress: the summary is the Congressional Research Service's, the action wording is the clerks', and the subjects are the Library of Congress's. How far it got is read from the actions themselves, taking the most recent one of each kind, so a bill that failed a vote and later passed is shown as having passed. Records come from this bill on Congress.gov and govinfo.gov; cost estimates are the Congressional Budget Office's, and the hearings are the printed hearings GovInfo publishes, which can appear months after the hearing.