S 3268 · 110th Congress 2007–2009, ended

Stop Excessive Energy Speculation Act of 2008

Latest action · Jul 25, 2008 Motion by Senator Reid to reconsider the vote by which cloture on the measure was not invoked (Record Vote Number 184) entered in Senate. (consideration: CR S7436)

Progress

Where this bill reached, and when. A stage with no date was not reached; one that failed a vote and later carried shows the date it carried.

  1. IntroducedJul 15, 2008
  2. Passed SenateNot reached
  3. Passed HouseNot reached
  4. To the PresidentNot reached
  5. Became lawNot reached

Summary

Stop Excessive Energy Speculation Act of 2008 - Amends the Commodity Exchange Act to extend its coverage to energy commodities such as petroleum products and natural gas.

Prohibits the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) from permitting a foreign board of trade to provide its members or other participants subject to CFTC jurisdiction direct access to its electronic trading and order matching system unless it meets specified requirements.

Authorizes the CFTC to require recordkeeping by any person either located within the United States or entering trades directly into the trade matching system of a foreign board of trade from the United States.

Subjects such persons to liability for violation of CFTC rules and regulations.

Directs the CFTC to convene a working group of international regulators to develop uniform international reporting and regulatory standards to ensure protection of energy futures markets from nonlegitimate hedge trading, excessive speculation, manipulation, location shopping, and lowest common denominator regulation, each of which poses systemic risks to all energy futures markets, countries, and consumers.

Defines "legitimate hedge trading" as transactions by commercial producers and purchasers of actual physical petroleum and energy commodities for future delivery and the direct counterparties to such trades.

Directs the CFTC to review oversight actions regarding all energy futures market participants or market activity in order to ensure that: (1) legitimate hedge trading is protected and promoted; and (2) excessive speculation is eliminated.

Requires the CFTC to set maximum speculative position limits on nonlegitimate hedge trading.

Instructs the CFTC to convene an advisory group to recommend an appropriate level for position limits designed for traders or entities that are not legitimate hedge traders.

Authorizes the CFTC to exercise oversight over any disturbance in a commodity market that disrupts its liquidity and price discovery function from accurately reflecting a commodity's supply and demand ("major market disturbance").

Requires the CFTC to identify each large over-the-counter transaction or class of such transactions in order to detect and prevent potential price manipulation of, or excessive speculation in, any contract listed for trading on a registered entity.

Instructs the CFTC to: (1) routinely require detailed reporting from index traders and swap dealers in markets under its jurisdiction; and (2) review the trading practices for index traders in markets under its jurisdiction to ensure that index trading is not adversely impacting the price discovery process.

Requires the CFTC to disaggregate and make public monthly: (1) the number of positions and total value of index funds and other passive, long-only positions in energy markets; and (2) data on speculative positions relative to bona fide physical hedgers in energy markets.

Directs the CFTC to appoint additional CFTC employees for enforcement purposes.

Establishes a Working Group on Energy Markets to: (1) identify the factors that affect the pricing of crude oil and refined petroleum products, including market speculation; and (2) assess the roles, missions, and structures of relevant federal agencies, interagency coordination, and the gaps that need to be filled for federal oversight and regulation of markets critical to energy security.

Amends the Department of Energy Organization Act to require each federal agency head to provide information to the Administrator of the Energy Information Administration for identification of each energy-producing company.

Establishes within such Administration a Financial Market Analysis Office responsible for financial analysis of energy markets.

Directs the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to investigate and report to certain congressional committees on the role of financial institutions in natural gas markets.

Directs the Comptroller General of the United States to study and report to certain congressional committees on: (1) the international regime for regulating the trading of energy commodity futures and derivatives; and (2) the effects of noncommercial speculators upon energy futures markets and energy prices.

Recorded votes 2

Newest first. Open one to see how every member voted.

Roll callQuestionResultDate
Senate 184Cloture Motion Rejected50–43Jul 25, 2008
Senate 183Cloture on the Motion to Proceed Agreed to94–0Jul 22, 2008

Cosponsors 17

Members who signed on, in the order they did. Signatures ran from Jul 15, 2008 to Jul 22, 2008; 4 are original cosponsors, there from the day it was introduced.

SeatCosponsorSigned on
D-NDByron L. DorganOriginalJul 15, 2008
D-NYCharles E. SchumerOriginalJul 15, 2008
D-WAPatty MurrayOriginalJul 15, 2008
D-ILRichard J. DurbinOriginalJul 15, 2008
D-MNAmy KlobucharJul 16, 2008
D-MDBarbara A. MikulskiJul 16, 2008
D-PARobert P. Casey Jr.Jul 16, 2008
D-DEThomas R. CarperJul 16, 2008
D-MDBenjamin L. CardinJul 17, 2008
D-VTPatrick J. LeahyJul 17, 2008
D-NJRobert MenendezJul 17, 2008
D-OHSherrod BrownJul 17, 2008
D-NJFrank R. LautenbergJul 21, 2008
D-RIJack ReedJul 21, 2008
D-ORRon WydenJul 21, 2008

Actions 17

Everything that happened, newest first.

  1. Jul 25, 2008Considered by Senate. (consideration: CR S7435-7436)
  2. Jul 25, 2008Cloture on the measure not invoked in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 50 - 43. Record Vote Number: 184. (consideration: CR S7435-7436; text: CR S7435)
  3. Jul 25, 2008Motion by Senator Reid to reconsider the vote by which cloture on the measure was not invoked (Record Vote Number 184) entered in Senate. (consideration: CR S7436)
  4. Jul 23, 2008Motion to proceed to measure considered in Senate. (consideration: CR S7095-7111, S7112-7124, S7124-7129)
  5. Jul 23, 2008Motion to proceed to consideration of measure agreed to in Senate by Voice Vote.

In the Congressional Record 15

Days the Record’s own index lists this bill, newest first, with the pages and the members it names. Pages starting H are the House, S the Senate, E Extensions of Remarks.

WhereIn the RecordMembersDate
SenateAmendments S9428John Barrasso R-WY (amendment), Ron Wyden D-OR (amendment)Sep 24, 2008
SenateDebate and remarks S7985Orrin G. Hatch R-UTAug 1, 2008
SenateDebate and remarks S7809, S7813, S7824–S7830, S7831Amendments S7978Byron L. Dorgan D-ND, Charles E. Schumer D-NY, Christopher S. Bond R-MO, John Cornyn R-TX, Jon Kyl R-AZ, Judd Gregg R-NH (amendment), Ken Salazar D-CO, Lamar Alexander R-TN, Mitch McConnell R-KY, Norm Coleman R-MN, Pete V. Domenici R-NM, Richard J. Durbin D-ILJul 31, 2008
SenateDebate and remarks S7718, S7721, S7725, S7751, S7752, S7763–S7767Arlen Specter D-PA, Harry Reid D-NV, Lamar Alexander R-TN, Michael B. Enzi R-WY, Mike Crapo R-ID, Pete V. Domenici R-NMJul 30, 2008
SenateDebate and remarks S7588, S7597–S7599, S7610Amendments S7631, S7702, S7703Byron L. Dorgan D-ND, John Barrasso R-WY (amendment), Ken Salazar D-CO (amendment), Larry E. Craig R-ID (amendment), Michael B. Enzi R-WY (amendment), Pete V. Domenici R-NM, Roger F. Wicker R-MS (amendment), Sam Brownback R-KS, Thad Cochran R-MS (amendment), Wayne Allard R-CO (amendment)Jul 29, 2008

Research

What has been written about this bill: committee reports, cost estimates, the sponsor’s authority statement, printed hearings and the Congressional Research Service’s work.

CRS reports 2

Congressional Research Service work that CRS links to this bill or the law it became, newest first.

Cite it 2

Products on other subjects that cite it, usually among other measures.

ProductTitleKindPublished
R40646Derivatives Regulation and Legislation Through the 111th Congress ArchivedReportJan 30, 2012
RL33521Gasoline Prices: Causes of Volatility and Congressional Response ArchivedReportNov 13, 2008

Amendments 164

Amendments offered to this bill.

AmendmentDescriptionOffered byStatus
SA 5089No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5090No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5091No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5092No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5093No description on fileRussell D. Feingold D-WISenate amendment submitted
SA 5094No description on fileChristopher J. Dodd D-CTSenate amendment submitted
SA 5095No description on fileChristopher J. Dodd D-CTSenate amendment submitted
SA 5096No description on fileJohnny Isakson R-GASenate amendment submitted
SA 5097No description on fileNorm Coleman R-MNSenate amendment submitted
SA 5098To establish the enactment date.Harry Reid D-NVConsidered by Senate. (consideration: CR S7435)
SA 5099To change the enactment date.Harry Reid D-NVConsidered by Senate. (consideration: CR S7435)
SA 5100To establish the effective date.Harry Reid D-NVConsidered by Senate. (consideration: CR S7435)
SA 5101To change the enactment date.Harry Reid D-NVConsidered by Senate. (consideration: CR S7435)
SA 5102To change the enactment date.Harry Reid D-NVConsidered by Senate. (consideration: CR S7435)
SA 5105No description on fileOlympia J. Snowe R-MESenate amendment submitted
SA 5106No description on fileOlympia J. Snowe R-MESenate amendment submitted
SA 5107No description on fileOlympia J. Snowe R-MESenate amendment submitted
SA 5108No description on fileMitch McConnell R-KYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5109No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5110No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5111No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5112No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5113No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5114No description on filePete V. Domenici R-NMSenate amendment submitted
SA 5115No description on filePete V. Domenici R-NMSenate amendment submitted
SA 5116No description on filePete V. Domenici R-NMSenate amendment submitted
SA 5117No description on filePete V. Domenici R-NMSenate amendment submitted
SA 5118No description on filePete V. Domenici R-NMSenate amendment submitted
SA 5119No description on fileLindsey Graham R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5120No description on fileLindsey Graham R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5121No description on fileChristopher S. Bond R-MOSenate amendment submitted
SA 5122No description on fileChristopher S. Bond R-MOSenate amendment submitted
SA 5123No description on fileChristopher S. Bond R-MOSenate amendment submitted
SA 5124No description on fileHerb Kohl D-WISenate amendment submitted
SA 5125No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5126No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5127No description on fileOlympia J. Snowe R-MESenate amendment submitted
SA 5128No description on fileWayne Allard R-COSenate amendment submitted
SA 5129No description on fileLamar Alexander R-TNSenate amendment submitted
SA 5130No description on fileJohn Ensign R-NVSenate amendment submitted
SA 5131No description on fileJim Bunning R-KYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5132No description on fileMary L. Landrieu D-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5133No description on fileLisa Murkowski R-AKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5134No description on fileLisa Murkowski R-AKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5135No description on fileJeff Bingaman D-NMSenate amendment submitted
SA 5136No description on fileJudd Gregg R-NHSenate amendment submitted
SA 5137No description on fileNorm Coleman R-MNSenate amendment submitted
SA 5138No description on fileJohn Barrasso R-WYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5139No description on fileJohn Barrasso R-WYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5140No description on fileRichard C. Shelby R-ALSenate amendment submitted
SA 5141No description on fileSusan M. Collins R-MESenate amendment submitted
SA 5142No description on fileSusan M. Collins R-MESenate amendment submitted
SA 5143No description on fileBob Corker R-TNSenate amendment submitted
SA 5144No description on fileMel Martinez R-FLSenate amendment submitted
SA 5145No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5146No description on fileDavid Vitter R-LASenate amendment submitted
SA 5147No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5148No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5149No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5150No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5151No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5152No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5153No description on fileLarry E. Craig R-IDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5154No description on fileTom Coburn R-OKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5155No description on fileMike Crapo R-IDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5156No description on fileMike Crapo R-IDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5157No description on fileMichael B. Enzi R-WYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5158No description on fileMichael B. Enzi R-WYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5159No description on fileMichael B. Enzi R-WYSenate amendment submitted
SA 5160No description on fileTed Stevens R-AKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5161No description on fileJohn Cornyn R-TXSenate amendment submitted
SA 5162No description on fileJohn Warner R-VASenate amendment submitted
SA 5163No description on fileJohn Warner R-VASenate amendment submitted
SA 5164No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5165No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5166No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5167No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5168No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5169No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5170No description on fileGordon H. Smith R-ORSenate amendment submitted
SA 5171No description on fileGeorge V. Voinovich R-OHSenate amendment submitted
SA 5172No description on fileJeff Sessions R-ALSenate amendment submitted
SA 5173No description on fileJeff Sessions R-ALSenate amendment submitted
SA 5174No description on fileJeff Sessions R-ALSenate amendment submitted
SA 5175No description on fileJames M. Inhofe R-OKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5176No description on fileJames M. Inhofe R-OKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5177No description on fileJames M. Inhofe R-OKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5178No description on fileJames M. Inhofe R-OKSenate amendment submitted
SA 5179No description on fileLindsey Graham R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5180No description on fileJoseph I. Lieberman I-CTSenate amendment submitted
SA 5181No description on fileJohn Thune R-SDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5182No description on fileRichard Burr R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5183No description on fileGordon H. Smith R-ORSenate amendment submitted
SA 5184No description on fileJack Reed D-RISenate amendment submitted
SA 5185No description on fileBenjamin L. Cardin D-MDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5186No description on fileMaria Cantwell D-WASenate amendment submitted
SA 5187No description on fileElizabeth Dole R-NCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5188No description on fileFrank R. Lautenberg D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5189No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5190No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5191No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5192No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5193No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5194No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5195No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5196No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5197No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5198No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5199No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5200No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5201No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5202No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5203No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5204No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5205No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5206No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5207No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5208No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5209No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5210No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5211No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5212No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5213No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5214No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5215No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5216No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5217No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5218No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5219No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5220No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5221No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5222No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5223No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5224No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5225No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5226No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5227No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5228No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5229No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5230No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5231No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5232No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5233No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5234No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5235No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5236No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5237No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5238No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5239No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5240No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5241No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5242No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5243No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5244No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5245No description on fileRobert Menendez D-NJSenate amendment submitted
SA 5246No description on fileMaria Cantwell D-WASenate amendment submitted
SA 5247No description on fileJim DeMint R-SCSenate amendment submitted
SA 5248No description on fileLarry E. Craig R-IDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5249No description on fileSam Brownback R-KSSenate amendment submitted
SA 5251No description on fileLarry E. Craig R-IDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5252No description on fileLarry E. Craig R-IDSenate amendment submitted
SA 5253No description on fileWayne Allard R-COSenate amendment submitted
SA 5258No description on fileJudd Gregg R-NHSenate amendment submitted
SA 5643No description on fileRon Wyden D-ORSenate amendment submitted

Related bills 1

Companion bills and other measures the record links to this one.

BillTitleRelationshipLatest action
S 3577Prevent Excessive Speculation ActRelated billSep 25, 2008

Titles 2

Every title it has carried, official and short, at each stage.

Official Title as Introduced
A bill to amend the Commodity Exchange Act, to prevent excessive price speculation with respect to energy commodities, and for other purposes.
Short Titles as Introduced
Stop Excessive Energy Speculation Act of 2008

Subjects

Assigned by the Library of Congress. Policy area: Finance and Financial Sector.

Text 1

Each version as it was printed, newest first.

  1. Jul 16, 2008Placed on Calendar Senate

Support LegiList

This page is free, carries no paywall, and is built and maintained by one person. If the record here is useful to you, a few dollars keeps it going.

Processed by Stripe in a separate window. LegiList never sees card details. Other amounts

Everything here is as published by Congress: the summary is the Congressional Research Service's, the action wording is the clerks', and the subjects are the Library of Congress's. How far it got is read from the actions themselves, taking the most recent one of each kind, so a bill that failed a vote and later passed is shown as having passed. Records come from this bill on Congress.gov and govinfo.gov; cost estimates are the Congressional Budget Office's, and the hearings are the printed hearings GovInfo publishes, which can appear months after the hearing.