HR 4280 · 108th Congress 2003–2005, ended

Help Efficient, Accessible, Low Cost, Timely Healthcare (HEALTH) Act of 2004

Latest action · May 13, 2004 Pursuant to the provisions of H. Res. 638, H.R. 4280 is laid on the table.

Progress

Where this bill reached, and when. A stage with no date was not reached; one that failed a vote and later carried shows the date it carried.

  1. IntroducedMay 5, 2004
  2. Passed HouseMay 12, 2004
  3. Passed SenateNot reached
  4. To the PresidentNot reached
  5. Became lawNot reached

Summary

(This measure has not been amended since it was introduced. The summary has been expanded because action occurred on the measure.)

Help Efficient, Accessible, Low Cost, Timely Healthcare (HEALTH) Act of 2004 - Sets forth provisions regulating lawsuits for health care liability claims concerning the provision of health care goods or services or any medical product affecting interstate commerce.

(Sec. 3) Sets a statute of limitations of three years after the date of manifestation of injury or one year after the claimant discovers the injury, or should have discovered the injury, whichever comes first, unless tolled on the basis of fraud, intentional concealment, or the presence of a foreign body in the injured person. Provides that lawsuits on behalf of minors under the age of six years must be commenced within three years of the manifestation of the injury or prior to their eighth birthday, whichever provides the longer period, with certain exceptions.

(Sec. 4) Allows the recovery of unlimited economic damages. Limits noneconomic damages to $250,000. Prohibits the jury from being informed of such limit. Makes each party liable only for the amount of damages directly proportional to such party's percentage of responsibility.

(Sec. 5) Requires court supervision over payment arrangements to protect against conflicts of interest that may reduce the amount of damages awarded that are actually paid to claimants. Allows the court to restrict the payment of attorney contingency fees. Limits the fees to a percentage based on the amount awarded.

(Sec. 6) Allows: (1) any party to a lawsuit involving injury or wrongful death to introduce evidence of collateral source benefits; and (2) any opposing party to then introduce evidence of any amount paid or contributed to secure the right to such benefits. Prevents providers of such benefits from recovering any amount against the claimant or receiving any lien or credit against the claimant's recovery or from being equitably or legally subrogated to the right of the claimant in a health care lawsuit involving injury or wrongful death.

(Sec. 7) Allows an award of punitive damages only if: (1) the claimant proves by clear and convincing evidence that the person acted with malicious intent to injure the claimant, or that such person deliberately failed to avoid unnecessary injury that such person knew the claimant was substantially certain to suffer; and (2) compensatory damages are awarded. Establishes procedural requirements for a claim for punitive damages. Enumerates the factors to be considered for an award of punitive damages, including the severity of harm caused by the conduct of the party, the duration of the conduct or any concealment of it, the profitability of the conduct, and any criminal penalties imposed. Limits punitive damages to the greater of $250,000 or two times the amount of economic damages awarded. Prohibits the jury from being informed of such limit.

Prohibits a punitive damage award in a product liability suit against a manufacturer, distributor, or supplier of a medical product that has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or that is generally recognized among qualified experts as safe and effective pursuant FDA conditions. Provides exceptions if: (1) the trier of fact finds by clear and convincing evidence that the product is substantially out of compliance with applicable labeling or packaging regulations; (2) a person knowingly misrepresented or withheld from the FDA required information that is material and causally related to the harm suffered by the claimant; or (3) an illegal payment is made to an FDA official to secure approval of the medical product. Prohibits a product liability suit against a medical care provider who prescribes or dispenses such a medical product approved by the FDA.

(Sec. 8) Provides for periodic payments of future damage awards over $50,000.

(Sec. 10) Exempts civil actions brought for vaccine-related injuries from this act to the extent that they are covered by the Public Health Service Act.

(Sec. 11) Preempts State law to the extent that it prevents the application of any provision of law established by this Act, but does not: (1) preempt State law that provides greater protections for health care providers or organizations or that specifies particular damage limits; or (2) affect any defenses available to a party under any other provision of State or Federal law.

(Sec. 13) Expresses the sense of Congress that a health insurer should be liable for damages for harm caused when it makes a decision as to what care is medically necessary and appropriate.

Recorded votes 2

Newest first. Open one to see how every member voted.

Roll callQuestionResultDate
House 166Passed229–197May 12, 2004
House 165Failed193–231May 12, 2004

Cosponsors 23

Members who signed on, in the order they did. Signatures ran from May 5, 2004 to May 12, 2004; 2 are original cosponsors, there from the day it was introduced.

SeatCosponsorSigned on
R-CAChristopher CoxOriginalMay 5, 2004
R-TXJoe BartonOriginalMay 5, 2004
D-GADavid ScottMay 6, 2004
R-PABill ShusterMay 11, 2004
R-MICandice S. MillerMay 11, 2004
R-CTChristopher ShaysMay 11, 2004
R-INDan BurtonMay 11, 2004
R-AZJ. D. HayworthMay 11, 2004
R-OHJohn A. BoehnerMay 11, 2004
D-PAJohn P. MurthaMay 11, 2004
R-PAJoseph R. PittsMay 11, 2004
R-ILJudy BiggertMay 11, 2004
R-GAMax BurnsMay 11, 2004
R-TXMichael C. BurgessMay 11, 2004
R-GAPhil GingreyMay 11, 2004
R-ILPhilip M. CraneMay 11, 2004
R-FLRic KellerMay 11, 2004
R-TXSam JohnsonMay 11, 2004
R-COScott McInnisMay 11, 2004
R-WVShelley Moore CapitoMay 11, 2004
R-VAVirgil H. Goode Jr.May 11, 2004
R-ILDonald A. ManzulloMay 12, 2004
R-PATodd Russell PlattsMay 12, 2004

Committees 2

Where it was sent and what each committee and subcommittee did with it, in order.

ChamberCommitteeWhat it did
HouseJudiciary Committee
Referred May 5, 2004
HouseEnergy and Commerce Committee
Referred May 5, 2004

Actions 12

Everything that happened, newest first.

  1. May 13, 2004Pursuant to the provisions of H. Res. 638, H.R. 4280 is laid on the table.
  2. May 12, 2004Considered under the provisions of rule H. Res. 638. (consideration: CR H2853-2874)
  3. May 12, 2004Rule provides for consideration of H.R. 4279, H.R. 4280 and H.R. 4281. Previous question shall be considered as ordered without intervening motions except motion to recommit with or without instructions. Measure will be considered read. Bill is closed to amendments.
  4. May 12, 2004DEBATE - Pursuant to House Resolution 638, the House proceeded with one hour of debate on H.R. 4280.
  5. May 12, 2004Mr. Conyers moved to recommit with instructions to Judiciary and Energy and Commerce. (consideration: CR H2869-2873; text: CR H2869-2872)

In the Congressional Record 5

Days the Record’s own index lists this bill, newest first, with the pages and the members it names. Pages starting H are the House, S the Senate, E Extensions of Remarks.

WhereIn the RecordMembersDate
HouseDebate and remarks H3098Michael C. Burgess R-TXMay 18, 2004
House · ExtensionsDebate and remarks E878, H3023Joe Baca D-CA, Michael C. Burgess R-TXMay 17, 2004
ExtensionsDebate and remarks E845, E867C. A. Dutch Ruppersberger D-MD, Edward J. Markey D-MA, Mark Udall D-COMay 14, 2004
HouseDebate and remarks H2923, H2996Edward R. Royce R-CA, Michael C. Burgess R-TXMay 13, 2004
House · ExtensionsDebate and remarks E840, H2822–H2829, H2853–H2874Text printed H2821, H2853–H2856Motions H2869Recorded votes H2835, H2873consideration (H. Res. 638), previous questionConyers motion to recommit (reform medical malpractice insurance business, limit frivolous lawsuits, and enhance patient access to medical care)Benjamin L. Cardin D-MD, Bill Shuster R-PA, Charles W. Stenholm D-TX, Christopher Cox R-CA, Dave Weldon R-FL, Deborah Pryce R-OH, Diana DeGette D-CO, Donna M. Christensen D-VI, F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr. R-WI, Fortney Pete Stark D-CA, Frank Pallone, Jr. D-NJ, Gene Green D-TX, George R. Nethercutt Jr. R-WA, James C. Greenwood R-PA, Jane Harman D-CA, Janice D. Schakowsky D-IL, Jeff Flake R-AZ, Jerry F. Costello D-IL, Joe Barton R-TX, John B. Shadegg R-AZ, John Conyers, Jr. D-MI (motion), John D. Dingell D-MI, Judy Biggert R-IL, Louise McIntosh Slaughter D-NY, Marsha Blackburn R-TN, Max Sandlin D-TX, Michael C. Burgess R-TX, Peter A. DeFazio D-OR, Philip M. Crane R-IL, Rahm Emanuel D-IL, Robert C. "Bobby" Scott D-VA, Robert Wexler D-FL, Ron Kind D-WI, Sam Johnson R-TX, Sheila Jackson Lee D-TX, Shelley Moore Capito R-WV, Sherrod Brown D-OH, Steve King R-IAMay 12, 2004

Related bills 5

Companion bills and other measures the record links to this one.

BillTitleRelationshipLatest action
HR 5Help Efficient, Accessible, Low-cost, Timely Healthcare (HEALTH) Act of 2003Related billMar 21, 2003
S 607HEALTH Act of 2003Related billMar 13, 2003
HRES 638Providing for consideration of the bill (H.R. 4279) to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide for the disposition of unused health benefits in cafeteria plans and flexible spending arrangements; for consideration of the bill (H.R. 4280) to improve patient access to health care services and provide improved medical care by reducing the excessive burden the liability system places on the health care delivery system; and for consideration of the bill (H.R. 4281) to amend title I of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 to improve access and choice for entrepreneurs with small businesses with respect to medical care for their employees.Related billMay 12, 2004
HR 4275To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to permanently extend the 10-percent individual income tax rate bracket.Related billMay 18, 2004
HR 4279To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide for the disposition of unused health benefits in cafeteria plans and flexible spending arrangements, to improve patient access to health care services and provide improved medical care by reducing the excessive burden the liability system places on the health care delivery system, and to amend title I of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 to improve access and choice for entrepreneurs with small businesses with respect to medical care for their employees.Related billMay 21, 2004

Titles 5

Every title it has carried, official and short, at each stage.

Official Title as Introduced
To improve patient access to health care services and provide improved medical care by reducing the excessive burden the liability system places on the health care delivery system.
Short Titles as Introduced
Help Efficient, Accessible, Low-Cost, Timely Healthcare (HEALTH) Act of 2004
Short Titles as Passed House
Help Efficient, Accessible, Low Cost, Timely Healthcare (HEALTH) Act of 2004
Short Titles as Passed House for portions of this bill
Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2004
Popular Titles
Medical Malpractice Liability Limitation bill

Subjects

Assigned by the Library of Congress. Policy area: Health.

Text 1

Each version as it was printed, newest first.

  1. May 5, 2004Introduced in House

Support LegiList

This page is free, carries no paywall, and is built and maintained by one person. If the record here is useful to you, a few dollars keeps it going.

Processed by Stripe in a separate window. LegiList never sees card details. Other amounts

Everything here is as published by Congress: the summary is the Congressional Research Service's, the action wording is the clerks', and the subjects are the Library of Congress's. How far it got is read from the actions themselves, taking the most recent one of each kind, so a bill that failed a vote and later passed is shown as having passed. Records come from this bill on Congress.gov and govinfo.gov; cost estimates are the Congressional Budget Office's, and the hearings are the printed hearings GovInfo publishes, which can appear months after the hearing.