Vermont · Bill 89 · 2023-2024 Session

An act relating to civil and criminal procedures concerning legally protected health care activity

  1. Introduced Jan 24, 2023
  2. In committee Jan 24, 2023
  3. Passed the House Feb 10, 2023
  4. Passed the Senate Apr 19, 2023
  5. To the governor May 4, 2023
  6. Became law May 10, 2023

What it does

The legislature's own summary of the bill, or its official long title.

This act defines “legally protected health care activity” for purposes of Vermont law to include reproductive health care services and gender-affirming health care services and reaffirms that access to such services is a legal right in Vermont. The act declares interference with legally protected health care activity, whether or not under the color of law, against the public policy of Vermont and the act shields…

Read the full title (654 words)

This act defines “legally protected health care activity” for purposes of Vermont law to include reproductive health care services and gender-affirming health care services and reaffirms that access to such services is a legal right in Vermont. The act declares interference with legally protected health care activity, whether or not under the color of law, against the public policy of Vermont and the act shields providers and patients from litigation seeking to interfere with these established health care services. The act identifies “abusive litigation” as litigation or other legal action to deter, prevent, sanction, or punish any person engaging in legally protected health care activity by filing or prosecuting any action in any other state where liability, in whole or part, directly or indirectly, is based on legally protected health care activity that occurred in Vermont. Lawsuits are considered to be based on conduct that occurred in Vermont if any part of any act or omission involved in the course of conduct that forms the basis for liability in the lawsuit occurs or is initiated in Vermont, whether or not such act or omission is alleged or included in any pleading or other filing in the lawsuit. The act creates a private right of action for a person who has been subject to abusive litigation to countersue for damages for the amount of any judgment issued in connection with any abusive litigation, and any and all other expenses, costs, or reasonable attorney’s fees incurred in connection with the abusive litigation and with the tortious interference action. The act establishes a policy of noncooperation with abusive litigation concerning legally protected health care. Vermont courts are prohibited from ordering a person found in Vermont to give testimony or a statement or produce documents or other things with any proceeding in a tribunal outside Vermont concerning abusive litigation involving legally protected health care activity. No public agency or employee, appointee, officer or official, or any other person acting on behalf of a public agency may knowingly provide any information or expend or use time, money, facilities, property, equipment, personnel, or other resources in furtherance of any interstate investigation or proceeding seeking to impose civil or criminal liability upon a person or entity for the provision, seeking or receipt of, or inquiring about legally protected health care activity that is legal in Vermont or assisting any person or entity providing, seeking, receiving, or responding to an inquiry about legally protected health care activity that is legal in Vermont. With respect to extradition, the Governor is directed not to surrender a person charged in another state as a result of engaging in legally protected health care activity unless the executive authority of the demanding state alleges in writing that the accused was physically present in the demanding state at the time of the commission of the alleged offense and that thereafter the accused fled from the demanding state. Finally, Act No. 14 Page 2 of 2 2023 VT LEG #370627 v.2 Vermont courts are prohibited from issuing a summons where a prosecution is pending in another state concerning legally protected health care activity or where a grand jury investigation concerning legally protected health care activity has commenced or is about to commence for a criminal violation of a law of the other state unless the acts forming the basis of the prosecution or investigation would also constitute an offense if occurring entirely in Vermont. The act establishes a civil offense for interference with access to a health care facility that is modeled after the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act (18 U.S.C. § 248) and permits persons who provide legally protected health care, persons who assist others in obtaining such care, and persons who exercise their legal right to obtain such services to participate in the Safe at Home address confidentiality program that is currently available to victims of domestic violence, stalking, sexual assault, or human trafficking.

Every action

41 steps, oldest first, as the legislature records them.

Show the 33 earlier steps
  1. CommitteeRead first time and referred to the Committee on Judiciary · House Committee on Judiciary
  2. HouseNotice Calendar: Favorable with Amendment
  3. HouseAction Calendar: Favorable with Amendment
  4. HouseRead second time
  5. CommitteeRep. LaLonde of South Burlington reported for the Committee on Judiciary · House Committee on Judiciary
  6. HouseRep. Donahue of Northfield and Higley of Lowell moved to amend the report of the Committee on Judiciary
  7. HouseRep. Bartholomew of Hartland raised a Point of Order
  8. HousePoint of order ruled well taken
  9. HouseAmendment of Rep. Donahue of Northfield and Higley of Lowell ruled not germane
  10. HouseReport of Committee on Judiciary agreed to
  11. HouseThird Reading ordered
  12. HouseAction Calendar: Third Reading
  13. HouseRead third time
  14. HouseRep. Small of Winooski demanded yeas and nays
  15. HouseRoll Call Results Passed -- Needed 72 of 143 to Pass -- Yeas = 130, Nays = 13
  16. HousePassed
  17. CommitteeRead 1st time & referred to Committee on Judiciary · Senate Committee on Judiciary
  18. SenateEntered on Notice Calendar
  19. SenateFavorable report with proposal of amendment by Committee on Judiciary
  20. SenateNew Business/Second Reading
  21. SenateFavorable report with proposal of amendment by Committee on Judiciary
  22. CommitteeRead 2nd time, reported favorably with proposal of amendment by Senator Hashim for Committee on Judiciary · Senate Committee on Judiciary
  23. SenateProposal of amendment by Committee on Judiciary agreed to
  24. Senate3rd reading ordered on roll call, requested by Senator Sears, Passed -- Needed 15 of 30 to Pass -- Yeas = 26, Nays = 4
  25. SenateNew Business/Third Reading
  26. SenatePending third reading, motion to amend Senate proposal of amendment offered by Senator(s) Lyons, Hashim, Baruth, Gulick, Hardy, Sears, Vyhovsky, and Weeks
  27. SenateMotion to amend Senate proposal of amendment agreed to
  28. SenateRead 3rd time & passed in concurrence with proposal of amendment
  29. HouseSenate Message: Passed in concurrence with proposal of amendment
  30. HouseNotice Calendar: Senate Proposal of Amendment
  31. HouseAction Calendar: Senate Proposal of Amendment
  32. HouseAction Calendar: Senate Proposal of Amendment
  33. HouseRep. LaLonde of South Burlington moved to postpone action until April 26, 2023, which was agreed to
  1. HouseAction Calendar: Senate Proposal of Amendment
  2. HouseRep. LaLonde of South Burlington moved to postpone action until April 27, 2023, which was agreed to
  3. HouseAction Calendar: Senate Proposal of Amendment
  4. HouseSenate proposal of amendment concurred in
  5. SenateHouse message: House concurred in Senate proposal of amendment
  6. HouseDelivered to the Governor on May 4, 2023
  7. GovernorSigned by Governor on May 10, 2023
  8. SenateHouse message: Governor approved bill on May 10, 2023

Roll calls

2 recorded votes: 2 on the floor, 0 in committee. Each shows how every member voted.

Read third time: roll Call Results · Full House

Passed 130–13
Feb 10, 2023 · journal entry
Yes 130 No 13 Not voting 6
Democrats: 98 yes, 1 no Independents: 3 yes, 0 no Libertarians: 1 yes, 0 no Other parties: 5 yes, 0 no Republicans: 23 yes, 12 no
How each member voted

Yes · 130

No · 13

Not voting · 1

Absent · 5

3rd reading ordered on roll call, requested by Senator Sears · Full Senate

Passed 26–4
Apr 18, 2023 · journal entry
Yes 26 No 4
Democrats: 22 yes, 0 no Other parties: 1 yes, 0 no Republicans: 3 yes, 4 no
How each member voted

Yes · 26

No · 4

Sponsors

The 3 members who introduced it, joined by 98 cosponsors: 92 Democrats, 4 Other partys, 2 Independents.

All 98 cosponsors

From Vermont's official records (legislature.vermont.gov), checked Nov 13, 2026. Text links go to the official versions; LegiList does not copy bill text.