The legislature's own summary of the bill, or its official long title.
With certain exceptions, the Nevada Ethics in Government Law (Ethics Law) governs the conduct of public officers and employees and, in certain circumstances, former public officers and employees after the end of their period of public service or employment. The Ethics Law is carried out and enforced by the Commission on Ethics, which is authorized to issue opinions interpreting the statutory ethical standards…
Read the full title (5,433 words)
With certain exceptions, the Nevada Ethics in Government Law (Ethics Law) governs the conduct of public officers and employees and, in certain circumstances, former public officers and employees after the end of their period of public service or employment. The Ethics Law is carried out and enforced by the Commission on Ethics, which is authorized to issue opinions interpreting the statutory ethical standards established by the Ethics Law and applying those standards to a given set of facts and circumstances. The Ethics Law also authorizes any state agency or the governing body of a county or city to establish a specialized or local ethics committee to complement the functions of the Ethics Commission. (Chapter 281A of NRS) Under the Ethics Law, the Commission is required to annually elect a Chair and Vice Chair who are assigned certain powers, functions and duties. (NRS 281A.210, 281A.220, 281A.240, 281A.300) Sections 2 and 17 of this bill provide for the Chair's powers, functions and duties to be assigned for a particular matter to the Vice Chair or another member of the Commission under certain circumstances. Section 17 also specifies that the Chair and Vice Chair be elected at the first fiscal meeting of each year. Section 8 of this bill authorizes the Chair, with certain exceptions, to grant not more than one extension of any time limit set forth in the Ethics Law, but the Chair cannot grant an extension of any time limit in the statute of limitations. Sections 31, 35 and 37-39 of this bill make conforming changes consistent with the authority of the Chair to grant the authorized extensions. Sections 3-5 of this bill define certain terms relating to proceedings before the Commission and the statutory ethical standards established by the Ethics Law. Sections 10, 14 and 46 of this bill make conforming changes to incorporate these definitions into the chapter. Section 6 of this bill: (1) restates more clearly the existing scope and applicability of the statutory ethical standards to the conduct of current and former public officers and employees; and (2) codifies the existing rule of construction that the standards are cumulative and supplement each other. Under Nevada's Open Meeting Law, the Commission may receive information regarding any litigation from its legal counsel and deliberate toward a decision regarding the litigation without holding a public meeting that complies with the Open Meeting Law. (NRS 241.015) Section 7 of this bill provides that during any period in which proceedings concerning a request for an advisory opinion or an ethics complaint are confidential under the Ethics Law, the Open Meeting Law does not apply to any meetings, hearings, deliberations or actions of the Commission involving: (1) any decisions in litigation related to the request for an advisory opinion or the ethics complaint; and (2) any delegation of authority to make such decisions in the litigation. Section 107 of this bill makes a conforming change to indicate this additional exception to the Open Meeting Law. The Ethics Law requires public officers to execute and timely file with the Commission written acknowledgments that they have received, read and understood the statutory ethical standards and that they have a responsibility to become familiar with any amendments to those standards. (NRS 281A.500) Section 9 of this bill requires the appropriate appointing authorities and administrative officials at the state and local level to: (1) compile a list of the public officers within their purview who are required to file the written acknowledgment of the statutory ethical standards; and (2) submit the list annually to the Commission. Under the Ethics Law, the Commission is authorized to make a decision relating to a matter or proceeding before the Commission and provide a written advisory opinion or written opinion in response to an ethics complaint. (NRS 281A.670-281A.760) Sections 11, 12, 15, 18, 19, 22, 24, 26, 28, 30-32, 34, 36-41 and 47 of this bill make various changes to distinguish between rendering a decision and issuing a written advisory opinion or issuing an opinion in response to an ethics complaint. The Ethics Law prohibits public officers and employees from engaging in certain unethical conduct, including conduct that benefits any persons to whom they have a commitment in a private capacity. (NRS 281A.400, 281A.420) Existing law defines the persons to whom public officers and employees have a “commitment in a private capacity” to include: (1) the spouse or domestic partner of the public officer or employee, any member of his or her household or any relative within the third degree of consanguinity or affinity; (2) any person who employs the public officer or employee, his or her spouse or domestic partner or any member of his or her household; (3) any person with whom the public officer or employee has a substantial and continuing business relationship; or (4) any person with whom the public officer or employee has any other commitment, interest or relationship that is substantially similar to the foregoing commitments, interests or relationships. (NRS 281A.065) Section 13 of this bill makes technical revisions to the definition of “commitment in a private capacity” that do not change the substantive meaning of the term. The Ethics Law requires the Chair to appoint review panels, consisting of three members of the Commission to review ethics complaints during the investigatory stage of the proceedings, and if a review panel determines that there is just and sufficient cause for the Commission to render an opinion in a matter, the members of the review panel generally cannot participate in any further proceedings of the Commission relating to the matter. (NRS 281A.220) However, the Ethics Law allows the members of the review panel to authorize the development of and approve a deferral agreement in the proceedings. (NRS 281A.730) Section 18 of this bill also allows one or more members of a review panel to participate as mediators or facilitators in any settlement negotiations with the consent of the parties during a specified period. The Ethics Law requires the Commission to appoint and prescribe the duties of the Commission Counsel, who is the legal advisor to the Commission and generally acts as legal counsel in any litigation in which the Commission or its members or staff are parties in an official capacity. (NRS 281A.250, 281A.260) Section 20 of this bill: (1) specifies the powers and duties of the Commission Counsel regarding any litigation in which the Commission or its members or staff are parties in an official capacity; and (2) clarifies that the Commission Counsel does not represent the interests of the Executive Director of the Commission in a judicial action or proceeding in which the Executive Director is named as a party to the action or proceeding based on the conduct of the Executive Director in his or her official capacity as a party to an adjudicative proceeding. The Ethics Law sets forth the jurisdiction of the Commission to investigate and take action regarding an alleged violation of the Ethics Law in any proceeding commenced by an ethics complaint if the ethics complaint is filed or initiated within 2 years after the alleged violation or reasonable discovery of the alleged violation. (NRS 281A.280) Section 21 of this bill similarly provides that the Commission has jurisdiction to gather information and issue an advisory opinion regarding past conduct that has occurred within 2 years before the date on which the request for an advisory opinion is filed. The Ethics Law authorizes the Commission to impose certain penalties, fees and costs against a person who prevents or interferes with, or attempts to prevent or interfere with, any investigation or proceeding under the Ethics Law or the discovery of a violation of the Ethics Law. (NRS 281A.790) Section 21 of this bill provides that the Commission has jurisdiction to investigate and take appropriate action regarding such an alleged violation in any proceeding commenced by a written notice of the charges within 2 years after the alleged violation or reasonable discovery of the alleged violation. Existing law requires the Commission to publish a manual explaining the Ethics Law. Section 22 of this bill replaces this requirement with a requirement to publish materials to educate public officers and employees on the Ethics Law. Section 23 of this bill: (1) authorizes the administration of oaths by a member of the Commission when appointed by the Chair to preside over any meetings, hearings or proceedings or by a certified court reporter; (2) authorizes the Chair to issue a subpoena during the course of an investigation for certain information; and (3) provides that any court proceeding commenced relating to a subpoena is deemed good cause for the Chair to grant an extension of the time limits that apply to proceedings concerning ethics complaints. The Ethics Law prohibits public officers and employees from using governmental time, property, equipment or other facility to benefit a significant personal or pecuniary interest of the public officers and employees or any persons to whom they have a commitment in a private capacity. The Ethics Law also contains certain limited-use exceptions that allow a limited use of governmental property, equipment or other facility for personal purposes if the limited use meets certain requirements. (NRS 281A.400) Section 25 of this bill revises these prohibitions and limited-use exceptions in several ways. First, one of the existing requirements for the limited-use exceptions is that the public officer or employee who is responsible for and has authority to authorize the limited use for personal purposes must have established a policy allowing the limited use. (NRS 281A.400) Section 25 clarifies the exception by providing that the limited use must be authorized by a written policy which was adopted before the limited use occurs. Second, one of the existing requirements for the limited-use exceptions is that the limited use for personal purposes must not create the appearance of impropriety. (NRS 281A.400) Section 25 defines the term “appearance of impropriety” to mean a reasonable person would find, based on the given set of facts and circumstances, that the limited use for personal purposes is inappropriate, disproportionate, excessive or unreasonable under that given set of facts and circumstances. The Ethics Law prohibits public officers and employees from using their position in government to secure or grant any unwarranted privileges, preferences, exemptions or advantages for themselves, any business entity in which they have a significant pecuniary interest or any person to whom they have a commitment in a private capacity. (NRS 281A.400) Section 25 also adds to the statutory ethical standards a prohibition against public officers and employees using their position or power in government to take actions or compel a subordinate to take any actions that would cause unwarranted harm or damage to another person to benefit a significant personal or pecuniary interest of the public officer or employee or any person to whom the public officer or employee has a commitment in a private capacity. With certain exceptions, the Ethics Law prohibits public officers and employees from acting upon a matter in which their personal or private interests may create potential conflicts of interests unless, at the time the matter is considered, they make a disclosure that is sufficient to inform the public of their potential conflicts of interests. (NRS 281A.420) Section 27 of this bill provides that, when public officers and employees make such a public disclosure, they are not required to disclose any information which is confidential under the terms of a contract or as a matter of law, such as a result of an attorney-client relationship, if they: (1) disclose all nonconfidential information and describe the general nature of the contract or law; and (2) abstain from acting upon the matter. The Ethics Law allows certain public officers to represent or counsel private persons for compensation before state or local agencies in which they do not serve. In addition, although the Ethics Law requires public officers to disclose such private representation or counseling when it may create potential conflicts of interests with their public duties, they are not required to abstain from acting on a matter because of those potential conflicts of interests. (NRS 281A.410, 281A.420) Section 27 requires public officers to abstain from acting on a matter under certain circumstances when such private representation or counseling results in conflicts of interests with their public duties. The Ethics Law prohibits certain former public officers and employees, for a 1-year “cooling-off” period after the termination of their public service or employment, from soliciting or accepting private employment from any entities regulated or awarded certain contracts by the agencies that employed the former public officers and employees. However, the Ethics Law also allows the Commission to grant relief from the strict application of the prohibition in specified circumstances. (NRS 281A.550) Section 28 provides that: (1) certain current and former public officers and management-level public employees are subject to the “cooling-off” period both during and after their public service or employment and cannot solicit or accept private employment from such entities under similar circumstances; and (2) the “cooling-off” period applies when certain current and former public officers and employees are or were in positions to materially affect or influence the awarding, renewing or amending of certain contracts by their employing agencies because they had the authority or responsibility to recommend, advise, negotiate, develop, draft, revise, review or approve any material terms of the contracts. In certain situations where current or former public officers and employees are alleged to have violated the “cooling-off” period, section 45 of this bill provides that the Commission must consider certain factors relating to the comparative value of the contract under the given set of facts and circumstances in assessing the severity of the violation and any penalties. Under the Ethics Law, the Legislative Counsel is required to prepare annotations to the Commission's published opinions for inclusion in the Nevada Revised Statutes. (NRS 281A.290) Sections 22 and 29 of this bill move and recodify this requirement. The Ethics Law authorizes a public officer or employee to file with the Commission a request for an advisory opinion to: (1) seek guidance relating to the propriety of his or her own past, present or future conduct under the statutory ethical standards; or (2) request relief from the strict application of certain provisions of the Ethics Law. (NRS 281A.675) Section 16 of this bill deletes duplicative provisions from the definition of a “request for an advisory opinion.” Section 30 authorizes the Commission to request additional information relating to the request for an advisory opinion from the requester or his or her legal counsel. With certain exceptions, the Commission is subject to the Open Meeting Law, which generally requires most meetings of public bodies to be open to the public. (Chapter 241 of NRS) However, under the Ethics Law, the Open Meeting Law does not apply to meetings, hearings, deliberations and actions of the Commission relating to requests for advisory opinions, although the requester of the advisory opinion may file a request with the Commission to hold a public meeting or hearing regarding the matter. (NRS 281A.690) Section 33 of this bill requires the requester to acknowledge his or her waiver of confidentiality in the request. Section 33 also provides that if the Commission grants such a request for a public meeting or hearing regarding the matter, the Commission must provide public notice of the meeting or hearing and the meeting or hearing must be open to the public and conducted in accordance with the regulations of the Commission, but the meeting or hearing is not subject to specific requirements of the Open Meeting Law. In addition to rendering advisory opinions, the Commission is also authorized by the Ethics Law to render opinions regarding the propriety of the conduct of public officers and employees under the statutory ethical standards in response to ethics complaints filed by a specialized or local ethics committee or a person or initiated by the Commission on its own motion. (NRS 281A.710) Section 34 of this bill authorizes the Executive Director to conduct a preliminary investigation into the propriety of the conduct of a public officer or employee to determine whether the Commission has jurisdiction and whether the Commission should initiate an ethics complaint on its own motion. Not later than 45 days after receiving an ethics complaint, the Ethics Law requires the Commission to determine initially whether it has jurisdiction over the ethics complaint and whether an investigation is warranted in the matter, unless the subject of the ethics complaint waives the time limit. (NRS 281A.715) Section 35 authorizes the Executive Director, during this initial period, to conduct a preliminary investigation to obtain additional information concerning the allegations in the ethics complaint to assist the Commission in making its initial determination. In addition, section 35: (1) eliminates, as unnecessary, the provision authorizing the subject to waive the time limit because the subject does not receive notice of the matter during this initial period, but only receives notice of the matter if the Commission determines that it has jurisdiction and an investigation is warranted; and (2) allows the Commission to dismiss an ethics complaint initiated on its own motion if it determines that the evidence is not sufficient to warrant an investigation in the matter. Under the Ethics Law, if the Commission determines that it has jurisdiction over an ethics complaint and an investigation is warranted, the subject of the ethics complaint is served with a notice of the investigation and provided with an opportunity to submit a response to that notice. (NRS 281A.720) Section 36 authorizes the Executive Director to grant, under certain circumstances, one or more extensions of the time limit to submit the response, but the Executive Director must set a specific and reasonable time period for such an extension. As part of the investigation, the Ethics Law permits the Executive Director to secure the subject's participation, attendance as a witness or production of books and papers under existing procedures. (NRS 281A.300) Section 36 clarifies that, regardless of whether the subject submits a response to the investigation, the Executive Director retains the authority during the course of the investigation to secure the subject's participation, attendance as a witness or production of books and papers under those existing procedures or any other law that provides such authority. Under the Ethics Law, a review panel is required to determine whether there is just and sufficient cause for the Commission to render an opinion in the matter. (NRS 281A.730) Section 38 of this bill requires that, after the review panel makes its determination, the review panel must serve a written notice of its determination on the public officer or employee who is the subject of the ethics complaint. The Ethics Law establishes various requirements regarding the adjudication of ethics complaints referred to the Commission for further proceedings. (NRS 281A.745-281A.760) Section 39 requires: (1) the Executive Director to issue a formal notice of charges to the subject of the ethics complaint regarding the allegations to be presented at an adjudicatory hearing; and (2) the Commission to provide the parties with a written schedule for discovery in order to prepare for the hearing. The Ethics Law requires the Commission to hold the hearing and render an opinion in the matter within a certain time period, unless waived by the subject, and requires the opinion to include findings of fact and conclusions of law. (NRS 281A.745, 281A.765) Section 39: (1) provides the Commission with more time to prepare the written opinion in the matter by requiring the Commission to issue the written opinion within a specified time period after the decision is rendered; and (2) clarifies that, in addition to including findings of fact and conclusions of law, the written opinion must otherwise comply with the requirements for a final decision under Nevada's Administrative Procedure Act. (NRS 233B.125) Section 43 of this bill makes a conforming change related to the contents of a written opinion. With certain exceptions, the Ethics Law requires, or in some cases allows, the Commission to keep the identity of certain persons who file ethics complaints confidential in order to protect those persons from potential harm. (NRS 281A.750) Section 40 of this bill extends the confidentiality of the requester to persons who worked for the same public body, agency or employer as the subject of the ethics complaint at the time of the alleged conduct, or if revealing the identity of the requester would otherwise reveal the identity of witnesses who work for the same public body, agency or employer. Section 40 also clarifies that: (1) such confidentiality extends to all materials that, if disclosed, would reveal the identity of the confidential requester; and (2) the identity of the confidential requester remains protected if the Executive Director does not intend to present the testimony of the confidential requester as evidence in the matter. However, if the Executive Director intends to present the testimony of the confidential requester as evidence in the matter, section 40 requires the Executive Director to disclose the name of the confidential requester only as a proposed witness in accordance with the schedule for discovery in the matter. Under the Ethics Law, the subject of an ethics complaint is authorized to submit a written discovery request for a list of proposed witnesses and a copy of any materials in the investigative file that the Executive Director intends to present as evidence in the matter. The Ethics Law also provides that the materials in the investigative file are confidential, except that any materials which the Executive Director presents as evidence in the matter become public records. (NRS 281A.755) Section 41 requires any written discovery request to be submitted in accordance with the schedule for discovery in the matter. Section 41 also provides that any materials which the Executive Director presents as evidence in the matter become public records after the Commission takes final action concerning the ethics complaint in a public meeting or hearing, but provides an exception if any of the materials are declared confidential by another law. In proceedings concerning an ethics complaint, the Ethics Law exempts from the Open Meeting Law: (1) any meeting or hearing held by the Commission to receive information or evidence concerning the ethics complaint; and (2) any deliberations of the Commission on such information or evidence. However, the Ethics Law does not exempt the Commission's actions concerning the ethics complaint from the Open Meeting Law. (NRS 281A.760) Section 42 of this bill generally exempts the Commission's actions concerning the ethics complaint from the Open Meeting Law. However, section 42 requires the Commission to take final action concerning the ethics complaint in a public meeting or hearing for which the Commission provides public notice and which is open to the public and conducted in accordance with the regulations of the Commission, but the meeting or hearing is not subject to specific requirements of the Open Meeting Law. The Ethics Law establishes various requirements regarding the disposition of ethics complaints and the imposition of remedies and penalties and, with respect to certain dispositions of ethics complaints and in determining whether a violation is willful, the Ethics Law requires the Commission to treat comparable situations in a comparable manner. (NRS 281A.785, 281A.790) Sections 44 and 45 of this bill require the Commission to carry out that duty to the extent practicable based on the given set of facts and circumstances. Section 47 clarifies that, based on a finding that a violation of the Ethics Law has been proven, the Commission is authorized to impose certain penalties using any manner in which the Commission is authorized to dispose of the matter. Section 48 of this bill makes technical conforming changes to the description of current and former public officers and employees in the Ethics Law. Section 108 of this bill addresses the applicability of certain provisions of sections 2-48 of this bill to various proceedings before the Commission. Sections 9, 9.5, 13.5, 15.5, 15.7, 25-27.5 and 48 of this bill remove legislative officers and employees from the jurisdiction of the Ethics Law, and sections 50-105 of this bill enact the Nevada Legislative Ethics Law (Legislative Ethics Law) to govern legislative officers and employees and, in certain situations, former legislative officers and employees after the end of their period of legislative service or employment. Sections 52-71 of this bill establish various definitions applicable to the Legislative Ethics Law. In particular, section 67 of this bill defines “legislative officer” as any current or former: (1) member of the Senate, Secretary of the Senate or officer of the Senate; (2) member of the Assembly, Chief Clerk of the Assembly or officer of the Assembly; or (3) officer of the Legislature, the Legislative Counsel Bureau or the Legislative Department of the State Government. However, the term does not include the Lieutenant Governor when acting in his or her official capacity as the President of the Senate. Section 65 of this bill defines “legislative employee” as any current or former employee, assistant, attache, intern or other staff employed with reference to the legislative duties of a Legislator or the Legislative Department, regardless of whether the position is paid or otherwise compensated. Under the Nevada Constitution, the Houses of the Legislature have adopted Standing Rules that establish various ethical standards for Legislators and other legislative officers and employees. (Nev. Const. Art. 4, § 6; Senate Standing Rule No. 23; Assembly Standing Rule No. 23; Joint Standing Rules Nos. 30-39) Section 73 of this bill provides that the Legislative Ethics Law supplements such Standing Rules and, to the extent that there is a conflict between the Standing Rules and the Legislative Ethics Law, the Standing Rules govern the conflict. Sections 51 and 72-76 of this bill set forth additional standards governing the interpretation, application and administration of the Legislative Ethics Law. Sections 77-83 of this bill establish legislative ethical standards which are similar to existing ethical standards for public officers and employees but which are tailored to the specific ethical demands of the Legislative Department. Existing law establishes general ethical standards to which public officers and employees are bound. (NRS 281A.400) Section 77 of this bill establishes similar provisions for the purpose of legislative officers and employees. Existing law restricts public officers and employees from representing or counseling private persons before certain public agencies. (NRS 281A.410) Section 78 of this bill establishes similar provisions for the purpose of legislative officers and employees. Existing law prohibits public officers and employees from taking certain actions relating to contracts between governmental entities and any business entity in which the public officer or employee has a significant pecuniary interest. (NRS 281A.430) Section 79 of this bill establishes similar provisions applicable to legislative officers and employees. Existing law prohibits a public officer or employee from accepting or receiving an honorarium under certain circumstances. (NRS 281A.510) Section 80 of this bill establishes similar provisions for the purpose of legislative officers and employees. Existing law prohibits a public officer or employee from requesting or otherwise causing a governmental entity to incur certain expenses or make expenditures to support or oppose ballot questions or candidates under certain circumstances. (NRS 281A.520) Section 81 of this bill establishes similar provisions prohibiting legislative officers and employees from engaging in such acts with regard to the Legislative Department. Existing law establishes certain “cooling-off” periods for public officers and employees relating to soliciting or accepting employment from certain entities under certain circumstances. (NRS 281A.550) Section 82 of this bill establishes similar provisions relating to legislative officers and employees. Existing law authorizes the Attorney General or the appropriate district attorney to void certain grants, contracts or leases entered into in violation of the Ethics Law and authorizes the Attorney General to take other actions to redress certain violations. (NRS 281A.540) Section 83 of this bill authorizes the Attorney General or appropriate district attorney to take similar actions to redress certain violations of the Legislative Ethics Law. To carry out and enforce the Legislative Ethics Law, sections 84-95 of this bill create the Senate Commission on Ethics (Senate Commission), Assembly Commission on Ethics (Assembly Commission) and Joint Commission on Ethics (Joint Commission), provide for the appointment and terms of their respective members and prescribe standards for their management, governance and proceedings. Section 109 of this bill directs the appointment and terms of the initial members of each Commission. Under section 87 of this bill, the Senate Commission has jurisdiction to: (1) hear ethics complaints brought against legislative officers and employees of the Senate; and (2) hear requests brought by such persons for advice on the legislative ethical standards. Under section 91 of this bill, the Assembly Commission has jurisdiction to: (1) hear ethics complaints brought against legislative officers and employees of the Assembly; and (2) hear requests brought by such persons for advice on the legislative ethical standards. Under section 95 of this bill, the Joint Commission has jurisdiction to: (1) hear ethics complaints brought against legislative officers and employees other than the officers or employees of the Senate or Assembly; and (2) hear requests brought by such persons for advice on the legislative ethical standards. Section 97 of this bill authorizes the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission and Joint Commission, as applicable, to conduct investigations and hold hearings to carry out the Legislative Ethics Law. Section 98 of this bill provides that all proceedings of the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, relating to the character, alleged misconduct, professional competence or physical or mental health of any person on matters regarding the legislative ethical standards and the materials relating thereto are confidential, unless the person subject to the proceedings waives such confidentiality. Section 106 of this bill makes a conforming change to the Public Records Law. Section 99 of this bill provides that a member of the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, is disqualified from serving during the consideration of a matter if: (1) the member is the subject of the ethics complaint; (2) the member requested the advice on the issue under consideration; or (3) a reasonable person in the member's situation could not exercise independent judgment on the matter. Section 100 of this bill authorizes an individual to file with the Legislative Counsel an ethics complaint against a legislative officer or employee. Section 100 requires the Legislative Counsel to review the ethics complaint and consult with the Chair of the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, to determine whether the Commission has jurisdiction over the complaint and whether an investigation is warranted in the matter. Finally, section 100 requires that: (1) if it is determined that the Commission does not have jurisdiction or an investigation is not warranted, the Legislative Counsel must send a written notice of such a determination to the individual who filed the ethics complaint; or (2) if it is determined that the Commission has jurisdiction and an investigation is warranted, the Legislative Counsel must send a written notice of the determination and a copy of the ethics complaint to the person who is subject to the ethics complaint. Section 74 of this bill requires the ethics complaint to be filed within 2 years after the alleged violation or reasonable discovery of the alleged violation. If the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, holds an adjudicatory hearing on an ethics complaint, section 101 of this bill establishes various procedural and evidentiary requirements for the adjudicatory hearing, including the burden and standard of proof. Section 102 of this bill requires the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, to dismiss an ethics complaint if the Commission finds that the violation of the legislative ethical standards has not been proven. Alternatively, if the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, finds that a violation of the legislative ethical standards has occurred, sections 102-104 of this bill authorize the Commission to: (1) issue a letter of caution or instruction to the legislative officer or employee; (2) admonish, reprimand or censure the legislative officer or employee; (3) impose civil penalties on the legislative officer or employee; or (4) take any other reasonable actions that the Commission determines will remedy the violation or deter similar violations, including referring the matter to the appropriate House for review and consideration. Section 105 of this bill also requires the Senate Commission, Assembly Commission or Joint Commission, as applicable, to refer the matter to the Attorney General or the district attorney, as appropriate, if the Commission believes that the violation of the legislative ethical standards constitutes a crime. Section 110 of this bill provides for the transition of jurisdiction for ethics proceedings brought against legislative officers and employees.