Memorandum

Proposed Revised Habitat for the Spotted Owl: Minimizing Regulatory Burdens

Federal Register citation
77 FR 12985โ€“12987
Document number
2012-5369
Issuing office
Executive Office of the President

The document

As published in the Federal Register, with the source's own line breaks.

Memorandum of February 28, 2012

Proposed Revised Habitat for the Spotted Owl:
Minimizing Regulatory Burdens

Memorandum for the Secretary of the Interior

Today, compelled by court order, the Department of the
Interior (Department) proposed critical habitat for the
northern spotted owl. The proposal is an initial step
in gathering important information that will inform a
final decision on what areas should be designated as
critical habitat for the spotted owl, based on a full
evaluation of all key criteria: the relevant science,
economic considerations, the impact on national
security, and a balancing of other factors.

Executive Order 13563 of January 18, 2011 (Improving
Regulation and Regulatory Review), explicitly states
that our ``regulatory system must protect public
health, welfare, safety, and our environment while
promoting economic growth, innovation, competitiveness,
and job creation'' (emphasis added). Consistent with
this mandate, Executive Order 13563 requires agencies
to tailor ``regulations to impose the least burden on
society, consistent with obtaining regulatory
objectives'' (emphasis added). Executive Order 13563
also requires agencies to ``identify and consider
regulatory approaches that reduce burdens and maintain
flexibility and freedom of choice'' while selecting
``those approaches that maximize net benefits.'' To the
extent permitted by law, our regulatory system must
respect these requirements.

The Endangered Species Act (ESA) states: ``[t]he
Secretary shall designate critical habitat . . . on the
basis of the best scientific data available and after
taking into consideration the economic impact, the
impact on national security, and any other relevant
impact, of specifying any particular area as critical
habitat'' (emphasis added). 16 U.S.C. 1533(b). The ESA
also provides that ``[t]he Secretary may exclude any
area from critical habitat if he determines that the
benefits of such exclusion outweigh the benefits of
specifying such area as part of the critical habitat,
unless he determines, based on the best scientific and
commercial data available, that the failure to
designate such area as critical habitat will result in
the extinction of the species concerned'' (emphasis
added). Id. Under the ESA, scientific, economic, and
other considerations are relevant to critical habitat
designations. Under a regulation issued by the
Department in 1984, however, the economic analysis
follows the scientific assessment, rather than being
presented simultaneously with it; one of the purposes
of this memorandum is to direct you to propose
revisions to that regulation.

Consistent with the ESA and Executive Order 13563,
today's proposed rule emphasizes the importance of
flexibility and pragmatism. The proposed rule notes the
need to consider ``the economic impact'' of the
proposed rule, outlines a series of potential
exclusions from the proposed critical habitat, and asks
for public comments on those exclusions and on other
possible exclusions. Private lands and State lands are
among the potential exclusions, based on a recognition
that habitat typically is best protected when
landowners are working cooperatively to promote forest
health, and a recognition--as discussed in the proposed
rule--that the benefits of excluding private lands and
State lands may be greater than the benefits of
including those areas in critical habitat.

Importantly, the proposed rule recommends, on the basis
of extensive scientific analysis, that areas identified
as critical habitat should be subject to active
management, including logging, in order to produce the
variety of stands of trees required for healthy
forests. The proposal rejects the traditional view that
land managers should take a ``hands off'' approach to
forest habitat in order to promote species health; on-
going logging activity may be needed to enhance forest
resilience.

In order to avoid unnecessary costs and burdens and to
advance the principles of Executive Order 13563,
consistent with the ESA, I hereby direct you to take
the following actions:

(1) publish, within 90 days of the date of this
memorandum, a full analysis of the economic impacts of
the proposed rule, including job impacts, and make that
analysis available for public comment;
(2) consider excluding private lands and State
lands from the final revised critical habitat,
consistent with applicable law and science;
(3) develop clear direction, as part of the final
rule, for evaluating logging activity in areas of
critical habitat, in accordance with the scientific
principles of active forestry management and to the
extent permitted by law;
(4) carefully consider all public comments on the
relevant science and economics, including those
comments that suggest potential methods for minimizing
regulatory burdens;
(5) give careful consideration to providing the
maximum exclusion from the final revised critical
habitat, consistent with applicable law and science;
and
(6) to the extent permitted by law, adopt the least
burdensome means, including avoidance of unnecessary
burdens on States, tribes, localities, and the private
sector, of promoting compliance with the ESA,
considering the range of innovative ecosystem
management tools available to the Department and
landowners.

Executive Order 13563 states that our regulatory system
``must promote predictability and reduce uncertainty.''
Uncertainty on the part of the public may be avoided,
and public comment improved, by simultaneous
presentation of the best scientific data available and
the analysis of economic and other impacts.
Accordingly, in order to provide more complete
information in the future regarding potential economic
impacts when critical habitat proposals are first
offered to the public, I direct you to take prompt
steps to propose revisions to the current rule (which,
as noted, was promulgated in 1984 and requires that an
economic analysis be completed after critical habitat
has been proposed) to provide that the economic
analysis be completed and made available for public
comment at the time of publication of a proposed rule
to designate critical habitat.

This memorandum is not intended to, and does not,
create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural,
enforceable at law or in equity by any party against
the United States, its departments, agencies, or
entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any
other person.

You are hereby authorized and directed to publish this
memorandum in the Federal Register.

THE WHITE HOUSE,

Washington, February 28, 2012

Sources

Every figure and line above comes from these; they open at the publisher.

Record fr-2012-5369, held as published by the Federal Register. LegiList reproduces the text and does not edit it.