Veto Message

Message to the House of Representatives Returning Without Approval the District of Columbia, Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and Education and Related Agencies Appropriations Bill

The document

As published in the Compilation of Presidential Documents, with the source's own line breaks.

Message to the House of Representatives Returning Without Approval the
District of Columbia, Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services,
and Education and Related Agencies Appropriations Bill

November 3, 1999

To the House of Representatives:

I am returning herewith without my approval H.R. 3064, the FY 2000
District of Columbia and Departments of Labor, Health and Human
Services, and Education, and Related Agencies appropriations bill.
I am vetoing H.R. 3064 because the bill, including the offsets
section, is deeply flawed. It includes a misguided 0.97 percent across-
the-board reduction that will hurt everything from national defense to
education and environmental programs. The legislation also contains
crippling cuts in key education, labor, and health priorities and
undermines our capacity to manage these programs effectively. The
enrolled bill delays the availability of $10.9 billion for the National
Institutes of Health, the Centers for Disease Control, and other
important health and social services programs, resulting in delays in
important medical research and health services to low-income Americans.
The bill is clearly unacceptable. I have submitted a budget that would
fund these priorities without spending the Social Security surplus, and
I am committed to working with the Congress to identify acceptable
offsets for additional spending for programs that are important to all
Americans.
The bill also fails to fulfill the bipartisan commitment to raise
student achievement by authorizing and financing class size reduction.
It does not guarantee any continued funding for the 29,000 teachers
hired with FY 1999 funds, or the additional 8,000 teachers to be hired
under my FY 2000 proposal. Moreover, the bill language turns the program
into a virtual block grant that could be spent on vouchers and other
unspecified activities. In addition, the bill fails to fund my proposed
investments in teacher quality by not funding Troops to Teachers ($18
million) and by cutting $35 million from my request for Teacher Quality
Enhancement Grants. These programs would bring more highly qualified
teachers into the schools, especially in high-poverty, high-need school
districts.
The bill cuts $189 million from my request for Title I Education for
the Disadvantaged, resulting in 300,000 fewer children in low-income
communities receiving needed services. The bill also fails to improve
accountability or help States turn around the lowest-performing schools
because it does not include my proposal to set aside 2.5 percent for
these purposes. Additionally, the bill provides only $300 million for
21st Century Community Learning Centers, only half my $600 million
request. At this level, the conference report would deny after-school
services to more than 400,000 students.
The bill provides only $180 million for GEAR UP, $60 million below
my request, to help disadvantaged students prepare for college beginning
in the seventh grade. This level would serve nearly 131,000 fewer low-
income students. In addition, the bill does not adequately fund my
Hispanic Education Agenda. It provides no funds for the Adult Education
English as a Second Language/Civics Initiative to help limited English
proficient adults learn English and gain life skills necessary for
successful citizenship and civil participation. The bill underfunds
programs designed to improve educational outcomes

for Hispanic and other minority students, including Bilingual Education,
the High School Equivalency Program (HEP), the College Assistance
Migrant Program (CAMP), and the Strengthening Historically Black
Colleges and Universities program.
The bill underfunds Education Technology programs, including
distance learning and community technology centers. In particular, the
bill provides only $10 million to community based technology centers,
$55 million below my request. My request would provide access to
technology in 300 additional low-income communities. The bill provides
$75 million for education research, $34 million less than my request,
and includes no funding for the Department of Education's share of
large-scale joint research with the National Science Foundation and the
National Institutes of Health on early learning in reading and
mathematics, teacher preparation, and technology applications.
The bill does not fund the $53 million I requested to provide job
finding assistance to 241,000 unemployment insurance claimants. This
means that these claimants will remain unemployed longer, costing more
in benefit payments. The bill also provides only $140 million of my $199
million request to expand services to job seekers at One-Stop centers as
recently authorized in the bipartisan Workforce Investment Act. The bill
funds $120 million of the $149 million requested for efforts to improve
access to One-Stops as well as continued support for electronic labor
exchange and labor market information. It funds only $20 million of the
$50 million requested for work incentive grants to help integrate
employment services for persons with disabilities into the mainstream
One-Stop system.
The bill also does not provide funding for Right Track Partnerships
(RTP). I requested $75 million for this new competitive grant program.
Designed to help address youth violence, RTP would become part of the
multi-agency Safe Schools/Healthy Students initiative, expanding it to
include a focus on out-of-school youth.
The bill provides $33 million less than my request for labor law
enforcement agencies, denying or reducing initiatives to ensure
workplace safety, address domestic child labor abuses, encourage equal
pay, implement new health law, and promote family leave. In particular,
the bill provides an inadequate level of funding for the Occupational
Safety and Health Administration, cutting it by $18 million, or 5
percent below my request.
The bill also fails to provide adequate funding for the Bureau of
International Labor Affairs (ILAB). The bill funds ILAB at $50 million,
$26 million below my request. The bill would prevent ILAB from carrying
out my proposal to work through the International Labor Organization to
help developing countries establish core labor standards, an essential
step towards leveling the playing field for American workers.
The bill's funding level for the Bureau of Labor Statistics is $11
million less than my request. The enrolled bill denies three important
increases that would: (1) improve the Producer Price Index, which
measures wholesale prices; (2) improve measures of labor productivity in
the service sector; and, (3) improve the Employment Cost Index, used to
help set wage levels and guide anti-inflation policy. It also denies
funding for a study of racial discrimination in labor markets.
The bill denies my request for $10 million to fund AgNet, even
though the Senate included report language that supports AgNet in
concept. AgNet, an Internet-based labor exchange, would facilitate the
recruitment of agricultural workers by growers and the movement of
agricultural workers to areas with employment needs.
The bill would cut the Social Services Block Grant (SSBG) by $209
million below FY 1999 and $680 million below my request. The SSBG serves
some of the most vulnerable families, providing child protection and
child welfare services for millions of children. In addition, the
failure to provide the Senate's level of $2 billion in advance
appropriations for the Child Care and Development Block Grant would mean
220,000 fewer children receiving child care assistance in FY 2001. The
bill also fails to fund my National Family Caregiver Support program,
which would provide urgently needed assistance to 250,000 families
caring for older relatives.

By funding the Title X Family Planning program at last year's level,
family planning clinics would be unable to extend comprehensive
reproductive health care services to an additional 500,000 clients who
are neither Medicaid-eligible nor insured. The bill also fails to fund
the Health Care Access for the Uninsured Initiative, which would enable
the development of integrated systems of care and address service gaps
within these systems.
The bill fails to fully fund several of the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention's (CDC) critical public health programs,
including:
<bullet>    childhood immunizations (-$44 million), so that
approximately 300,000 children may not receive the full
complement of recommended childhood vaccinations;
<bullet>    infectious diseases (-$36 million), which will impair CDC's
ability to investigate outbreaks of diseases such as the
West Nile virus in New York;
<bullet>    domestic HIV prevention (-$4 million);
<bullet>    race and health demonstrations (-$5 million), which will
impair better understanding of how to reduce racial
disparities in health; and,
<bullet>    health statistics (-$10 million) for key data collection
activities such as the National Health and Nutrition
Examination Survey and health information on racial and
ethnic population groups.
The Congress has failed to fund any of the $59 million increase I
requested for the Mental Health Block Grant, which would diminish
States' capacity to serve the mentally ill.
In addition, the Congress has underfunded my request for the
Substance Abuse Block Grant by $30 million, and has underfunded other
substance abuse treatment grants by a total of $45 million. These
reductions would widen the treatment gap in FY 2000 and jeopardize the
Federal Government's ability to meet the National Drug Control Strategy
performance target to reduce the drug treatment gap by 50 percent by FY
2007.
The bill provides only half of the $40 million requested for
graduate education at Children's Hospitals, which play an essential role
in education the Nation's physicians, training 25 percent of
pediatricians and over half of many pediatric subspecialists.
The bill underfunds the Congressional Black Caucus' AIDS Initiative
in the Public Health and Social Services Emergency Fund by $15 million,
thereby reducing current efforts to prevent the spread of HIV. By not
fully funding this program, the scope of HIV/AIDS prevention, education,
and outreach activities available to slow the spread of HIV/AIDS in
minority communities will be more limited.
The bill fails to fund Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA)
program management adequately. These reductions would severely impede
HCFA's ability to ensure the quality of nursing home care through the
Nursing Home Initiative. The bill does not adequately fund the request
for Medicare+Choice user fees. This decrease would force HCFA to scale
back the National Medicare Education Campaign. The Congress has not
passed the proposed user fees totaling $194.5 million that could free up
resources under the discretionary caps for education and other
priorities.
The bill includes a provision that would prevent funds from being
used to administer the Medicare+Choice Competitive Pricing Demonstration
Project in Kansas and Arizona. These demonstrations which are supported
by MEDPAC and other independent health policy experts, were passed by
the Congress as part of the Balanced Budget Act in order to provide
valuable information regarding the use of competitive pricing
methodologies in Medicare. The information that we could learn from
these demonstrations is particularly relevant as we consider the
important task of reforming Medicare.
The bill contains a highly objectionable provision that would delay
the implementation of HHS' final Organ Procurement and Transplantation
rule for 90 days. This rule, which was strongly validated by an
Institute of Medicine report, provides a more equitable system of
treatment for over 63,000 Americans waiting for an organ transplant; its
implementation would likely prevent the deaths of hundreds of Americans.
Since almost 5,000 people die each year waiting for

an organ transplant, we must be allowed to move forward on this issue
and implement the rule without further delay.
The bill does not provide any of the $9.5 million I requested for
HHS' Office of the General Counsel and Departmental Appeals Board to
handle legal advice, regulations review, and litigation support, and to
conduct hearings and issue decisions on nursing home enforcement cases
as part of my Nursing Home Initiative. This would increase the backlog
of nursing home appeals and impair Federal oversight of nursing home
quality and safety standards. A reduction in funds for enforcement is
inconsistent with the concerns that the GAO and the Congress have raised
about this issue.
The bill cuts funds to counter bioterrorism. It funds less than half
my request for CDC's stockpile, limiting the amount of vaccines,
antibiotics, and other medical supplies that can be stockpiled to deploy
in the event of a chemical or biological attack. In addition, the bill
does not include $13.4 million for critical FDA expedited regulatory
review/approval of pharmaceuticals to combat chemical and biological
agent weapons.
The bill provides full funding of $350 million in FY 2002 for the
Corporation for Public Broadcasting. However, the bill provides only $10
million of the $20 million requested for the digital transition
initiative in FY 2000. This funding is required to help the public
broadcasting system meet the Federal deadline to establish digital
broadcasting capability by May 1, 2003.
The enrolled bill delays the availability of $10.9 billion of
funding until September 29, 2000. While modest levels of delayed
obligations could potentially be sustained without hurting the affected
programs, the levels in the enrolled bill are excessive, resulting in
delays in NIH research grants, delays in CDC immunizations for children,
and delays in the delivery of health services to low income Americans
through community health centers and rural health clinics.
The bill also seriously underfunds critical Departmental management
activities in the Departments of Labor and Education and the Social
Security Administration (SSA). For Education, these reductions would
hamstring efforts to replace the Department's accounting system and
undermine the new Performance-Based Organization's plans to streamline
and modernize student aid computer systems. Reductions to the Department
of Labor (DOL) would undercut the agency's ability to comply with the
requirements of the Clanger-Cohen and Computer Security Acts, adjudicate
contested claims in several of its benefits programs, and examine and
update the 1996 study on Family and Medical leave policies. For SSA, the
reductions would result in significantly longer waiting times for
disability applicants and millions of individuals who visit SSA field
offices.
In adopting an across-the-board reduction, the Congress has
abdicated its responsibility to make tough choices. Governing is about
making choices and selecting priorities that will serve the national
interest. By choosing an across-the-board cut, the Congress has failed
to meet that responsibility.
This across-the-board cut would result in indiscriminate reductions
in important areas such as education, the environment, and law
enforcement. In addition, this cut would have an adverse impact on
certain national security programs. The indiscriminate nature of the cut
would require a reduction of over $700 million for military personnel,
which would require the military services to make cuts in recruiting and
lose up to 48,000 military personnel.
In adopting this cost-saving technique, the Congress is asserting
that it will not have to dip into the Social Security surplus. However,
this cut does not eliminate the need to dip into the Social Security
surplus.
For these reasons, this across-the-board cut is not acceptable.
In addition to the specific program cuts and the 0.97 percent
across-the-board reduction, the bill contains a $121 million reduction
in salaries and expenses for the agencies funded by this bill,
exacerbating the problems caused by the bill's underfunding of critical
Departmental management activities. If, for example, the $121 million
reduction were allocated proportionately across all agencies funded in
the Labor/HHS/Education bill, HHS would have to absorb an approximately
$55 million reduction to its salaries and expenses accounts, Labor would
be cut by about $14 million, Education by

about $5 million, and SSA by some $45 million. This would dramatically
affect the delivery of essential human services and education programs
and the protection of employees in the workplace.
With respect to the District of Columbia component of the bill, I am
pleased that the majority and minority in the Congress were able to come
together to pass a version of the District of Columbia Appropriations
Bill that I would sign if presented to me separately and as it is
currently constructed. While I continue to object to remaining riders,
some of the highly objectionable provisions that would have intruded
upon local citizens' right to make decisions about local matters have
been modified from previous versions of the bill. That is a fair
compromise. We will continue to strenuously urge the Congress to keep
such riders off of the FY 2001 D.C. Appropriations Bill.
I commend the Congress for providing the Federal funds I requested
for the District of Columbia. The bill includes essential funding for
District Courts and Corrections and the D.C. Offender Supervision Agency
and provides requested funds for a new tuition assistance program for
District of Columbia residents. The bill also includes funding to
promote the adoption of children in the District's foster care system,
to support the Children's National Medical Center, to assist the
Metropolitan Police Department in eliminating open-air drug trafficking
in the District, and for drug testing and treatment, among other
programs. However, I continue to object to remaining riders that violate
the principles of home rule.
I look forward to working with the Congress to craft an
appropriations bill that I can support, and to passage of one that will
facilitate our shared objectives.
William J. Clinton
The White House,
November 3, 1999.

Legislation named

Bills this document refers to, on the congressional side of the record.

Bill Title
H.R. 3064 (106th) โ€”

Veto record

This document is the message returning a bill to Congress.

Bill Override Vetoed
H.R. 3064 Not attempted November 3, 1999

Sources

Every figure and line above comes from these; they open at the publisher.

Record cpd-wcpd-1999-11-08-pg2237, held as published by the GovInfo. LegiList reproduces the text and does not edit it.