Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act of 2016
Latest action · Feb 29, 2016 Received in the Senate and Read twice and referred to the Committee on the Judiciary.
Progress
Where this bill reached, and when. A stage with no date was not reached; one that failed a vote and later carried shows the date it carried.
- IntroducedSep 28, 2015
- Passed HouseFeb 25, 2016
- Passed SenateNot reached
- To the PresidentNot reached
- Became lawNot reached
Summary
Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act of 2016
(Sec. 2) This bill amends procedures under which federal courts determine whether a case that was removed from a state court to a federal court on the basis of a diversity of citizenship among the parties may be remanded back to state court upon a motion opposed on fraudulent joinder grounds that: (1) one or more defendants are citizens of the same state as one or more plaintiffs, or (2) one or more defendants properly joined and served are citizens of the state in which the action was brought.Joinder of such a defendant is fraudulent if the court finds:
- actual fraud in the pleading of jurisdictional facts with respect to that defendant,
- state law would not plausibly impose liability on that defendant,
- state or federal law bars all claims in the complaint against that defendant, or
- no good faith intention to prosecute the action against that defendant or to seek a joint judgment including that defendant.
In determining whether to grant or deny such a motion for remand, the court: (1) may permit pleadings to be amended; and (2) must consider the pleadings, affidavits, and other evidence submitted by the parties.
A federal court finding that all such defendants have been fraudulently joined must: (1) dismiss without prejudice the claims against those defendants, and (2) deny the motion for remand.
Recorded votes 3
Newest first. Open one to see how every member voted.
| Roll call | Question | Result | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| House 89 | On Passage | Passed229–189 | Feb 25, 2016 |
| House 88 | On Motion to Recommit with Instructions | Failed180–239 | Feb 25, 2016 |
| House 87 | On Agreeing to the Amendment | Failed178–237 | Feb 25, 2016 |
Cosponsors
Members who signed on, in the order they did.
Committees 2
Where it was sent and what each committee and subcommittee did with it, in order.
| Chamber | Committee | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| House | Judiciary Committee | Referred Sep 28, 2015Markup Feb 3, 2016Reported Feb 16, 2016 |
| Constitution and Limited Government Subcommittee | Referred Nov 3, 2015Discharged Jan 29, 2016 | |
| Senate | Judiciary Committee | Referred Feb 29, 2016 |
Actions 34
Everything that happened, newest first.
- Feb 29, 2016Received in the Senate and Read twice and referred to the Committee on the Judiciary.
- Feb 25, 2016Considered under the provisions of rule H. Res. 618. (consideration: CR H907-915)
- Feb 25, 2016Rule provides for consideration of H.R. 3624 with 1 hour of general debate. Previous question shall be considered as ordered without intervening motions except motion to recommit with or without instructions. Measure will be considered read. Specified amendments are in order. It shall be in order to consider as an original bill for the purpose of amendment under the five-minute rule the amendment in the nature of a substitute recommended by the Committee on the Judiciary now printed in the bill.
- Feb 25, 2016House resolved itself into the Committee of the Whole House on the state of the Union pursuant to H. Res. 618 and Rule XVIII.
- Feb 25, 2016The Speaker designated the Honorable Garret Graves to act as Chairman of the Committee.
- Feb 25, 2016GENERAL DEBATE - The Committee of the Whole proceeded with one hour of general debate on H.R. 3624.
- Feb 25, 2016DEBATE - Pursuant to the provisions of H.Res. 618, the Committee of the Whole proceeded with 10 minutes of debate on the Buck (CO) amendment No. 1.
- Feb 25, 2016DEBATE - Pursuant to the provisions of H. Res 618, the Committee of the Whole proceeded with 10 minutes of debate on the Cartwright (PA) amendment No. 2.
- Feb 25, 2016POSTPONED PROCEEDINGS - At the conclusion of debate on the Cartwright amendement No. 2 the Chair put the question on adoption of the amendment and by voice vote annouced that the noes had prevailed. Mr. Cartwright demanded a recorded vote and the Chair postponed further proceedings on the question of adoption of the amendment until a time to be announced.
- Feb 25, 2016Mr. Buck moved that the Committee rise.
- Feb 25, 2016On motion that the Committee rise Agreed to by voice vote.
- Feb 25, 2016Committee of the Whole House on the state of the Union rises leaving H.R. 3624 as unfinished business.
- Feb 25, 2016Considered as unfinished business. (consideration: CR H915-918)
- Feb 25, 2016The House resolved into Committee of the Whole House on the state of the Union for further consideration.
- Feb 25, 2016UNFINISHED BUSINESS - The Chair announced that the unfinished business was the question of adoption of amendments which had been debated earlier and on which further proceedings had been postponed.
- Feb 25, 2016The House rose from the Committee of the Whole House on the state of the Union to report H.R. 3624.
- Feb 25, 2016The previous question was ordered pursuant to the rule. (consideration: CR H916)
- Feb 25, 2016The House adopted the amendment in the nature of a substitute as agreed to by the Committee of the Whole House on the state of the Union. (text of amendment in the nature of a substitute: CR H913)
- Feb 25, 2016Mrs. Watson Coleman moved to recommit with instructions to the Committee on the Judiciary. (consideration: CR H916; text: CR H916)
- Feb 25, 2016Floor summary: DEBATE - The House proceeded with 10 minutes of debate on the Watson Coleman motion to recommit with instructions. The instructions contained in the motion seek to require the bill to be reported back to the House with an amendment to add an exemption to the underlying bill for cases in which the plaintiff seeks relief in connection with the sexual abuse or exploitation of a minor.
- Feb 25, 2016The previous question on the motion to recommit with instructions was ordered without objection. (consideration: CR H917)
- Feb 25, 2016On motion to recommit with instructions Failed by recorded vote: 180 - 239 (Roll no. 88).
- Feb 25, 2016Passed/agreed to in House: On passage Passed by recorded vote: 229 - 189 (Roll no. 89).
- Feb 25, 2016Motion to reconsider laid on the table Agreed to without objection.
- Feb 24, 2016Rule H. Res. 618 passed House.
- Feb 23, 2016Rules Committee Resolution H. Res. 618 Reported to House. Rule provides for consideration of H.R. 3624 with 1 hour of general debate. Previous question shall be considered as ordered without intervening motions except motion to recommit with or without instructions. Measure will be considered read. Specified amendments are in order. It shall be in order to consider as an original bill for the purpose of amendment under the five-minute rule the amendment in the nature of a substitute recommended by the Committee on the Judiciary now printed in the bill.
- Feb 16, 2016Reported (Amended) by the Committee on Judiciary. H. Rept. 114-422.
- Feb 16, 2016Placed on the Union Calendar, Calendar No. 321.
- Feb 3, 2016Committee Consideration and Mark-up Session Held.
- Feb 3, 2016Ordered to be Reported (Amended) by the Yeas and Nays: 13 - 10.
- Jan 29, 2016Subcommittee on the Constitution and Civil Justice Discharged.
- Nov 3, 2015Referred to the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Civil Justice.
- Sep 28, 2015Introduced in House
- Sep 28, 2015Referred to the House Committee on the Judiciary.
In the Congressional Record 3
Days the Record’s own index lists this bill, newest first, with the pages and the members it names. Pages starting H are the House, S the Senate, E Extensions of Remarks.
| Where | In the Record | Members | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| House | Debate and remarks H907–H918Text printed H913Amendments H913Motions H916Recorded votes H915, H917Cartwright amendment (allow joinder of certain State court cases when the plaintiff seeks compensation resulting from the bad faith of an insurer)Watson Coleman motion to recommit (allow joinder of certain State court cases when the plaintiff seeks compensation in connection with sexual abuse or exploitation of a minor) | Bob Goodlatte R-VA, Bonnie Watson Coleman D-NJ (motion), Henry C. "Hank" Johnson, Jr. D-GA, Jerrold Nadler D-NY, John Conyers, Jr. D-MI, Ken Buck R-CO (amendment), Matt Cartwright D-PA (amendment), Sheila Jackson Lee D-TX, Steve Cohen D-TN | Feb 25, 2016 |
| House | Debate and remarks H869–H874Text printed H869Amendments H872Recorded votes H873consideration (H. Res. 618), previous question | Bill Pascrell, Jr. D-NJ, Doug Collins R-GA, James P. McGovern D-MA (amendment), John A. Yarmuth D-KY | Feb 24, 2016 |
| House | Declaratory Statements H856 | — | Feb 23, 2016 |
Research
What has been written about this bill: committee reports, cost estimates, the sponsor’s authority statement, printed hearings and the Congressional Research Service’s work.
Committee report
Congressional Budget Office cost estimate
- Feb 16, 2016H.R. 3624, Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act of 2016As ordered reported by the House Committee on the Judiciary on February 3, 2016
Constitutional authority
The sponsor’s statement, as printed in the Congressional Record, vol. 161, no. 140, September 28, 2015, page H6307.
Printed hearings 1
Hearings whose printed record names this bill, newest first: hearings on it, and wider hearings where it came up.
| Number | Hearing | Committee | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Serial No. 114-44 | FRAUDULENT JOINDER PREVENTION ACT OF 201580 pages | Judiciary Committee | Sep 29, 2015 |
Amendments 2
Amendments offered to this bill.
| Amendment | Description | Offered by | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| HAmdt 944 | Amendment makes technical changes to the bill and strikes references to multiple defendants and replaces them with references to single defendants to clarify that even if one in-state defendant has a legitmate connection to a case, the case can remain in State court. | Ken Buck R-CO | On agreeing to the Buck amendment (A001) Agreed to by voice vote. |
| HAmdt 945 | Amendment sought to create a separate exception for plaintiffs seeking compensation resulting from the bad faith of an insurer. | Matt Cartwright D-PA | On agreeing to the Cartwright amendment (A002) Failed by recorded vote: 178 - 237 (Roll no. 87). |
Related bills 1
Companion bills and other measures the record links to this one.
| Bill | Title | Relationship | Latest action |
|---|---|---|---|
| HRES 618 | Providing for consideration of the bill (H.R. 3624) to amend title 28, United States Code, to prevent fraudulent joinder. | Procedurally related | Feb 24, 2016 |
Titles 4
Every title it has carried, official and short, at each stage.
- Official Title as Introduced
- To amend title 28, United States Code, to prevent fraudulent joinder.
- Short Titles as Introduced
- Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act of 2015
- Short Titles as Reported to House
- Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act of 2016
- Short Titles as Passed House
- Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act of 2016
Subjects
Assigned by the Library of Congress. Policy area: Law.
Text 4
Each version as it was printed, newest first.
- Feb 29, 2016Referred in Senate
- Feb 25, 2016Engrossed in House
- Feb 16, 2016Reported in House
- Sep 28, 2015Introduced in House
Support LegiList
This page is free, carries no paywall, and is built and maintained by one person. If the record here is useful to you, a few dollars keeps it going.
Everything here is as published by Congress: the summary is the Congressional Research Service's, the action wording is the clerks', and the subjects are the Library of Congress's. How far it got is read from the actions themselves, taking the most recent one of each kind, so a bill that failed a vote and later passed is shown as having passed. Records come from this bill on Congress.gov and govinfo.gov; cost estimates are the Congressional Budget Office's, and the hearings are the printed hearings GovInfo publishes, which can appear months after the hearing.